Have you decided whether Eden is better than Makinson yet? You seem to have gone very quiet on the subject.

Obviously he isn’t.

But what about your stats, especially top try scorer? Just a few posts ago this was 'proof'...Ah! I get it! It's only proof if it suits your argument.



I know you're a troll but at least have some pride in your work. You're not even good at trolling. You can't maintain a coherent argument for more than a couple of posts.

I go away on holiday for a couple of weeks and the site gets infected with posters from the Parr School of Science. They all have birthdays on 29th of February so only get to celebrate every four years and then disappear.

we've had to put up with this goit since last year on our board, he must be a groundsman in Superleague he moves the goalposts that much.

Nice try but that wasn’t the only stat that shows Percival is better than Gildart.

what was? international tries? trophies won? erm.....

=#0000BF"That’s a load of nonsense. Should we get rid of the top try scorer award because everyone plays in completely different teams? Their stats are absolutely comparable, they both play centre and face the same opposition"

There's no 'nice try' about it. You claimed that stats such as top try scorer proved who was best in a given position regardless of any other factors. You can't have it both ways. So which is it? Is Eden better than Makinson or do you concede that you were talking b0llocks?

There isn’t one Wigan player who would get in saints team whilst we have reserves who would walk into yours/

That’s why we are top and you are praying you avoid relegation lol

We’re one win from being back in the play off places. Can’t wait for you guys to bottle it again.

As others have said, it’s nice having some of you back on here after you’ve been so e for the past decade.

LeBrons that bored he’s just posting the same troll posts now.

Regards

Saints are unbeatable ?

They’ll probably lose Friday

They will be terrified if we sneak into the playoffs.

We all will! I seriously wouldn't put it past Wigan to win it again, it's in their DNA.

Burgess and Gildart.....other than that I’m struggling to disagree.

Farrell O’Loughlin would certainly get in, Williams is better than Fages as well

No one can write Wigan off because they know how to win the games that matter.

I'm sure the RFL & sky would love it if Wigan did damage in the play offs.

Not on this years form they wouldn’t.

It’s not about form though, it’s about who’s the better player (by a distance) over a long period of time when it comes to saying who’d get in each other’s sides. Had Burgess, Gildart, Williams, Farrell, Lockers etc been coached by Holbrook in a side as dominant as Saints have been then clearly their form would be better.

Williams vs Fages is probably the ideal case in point. Yes his form hasn’t been great, yes you could probably say Fages has had a better season then him in relative terms (to their ability) but had Williams been playing on the back of Thompson, Roby and Walmsley all season then it would’ve been carnage, total and utter carnage in comparison to what the ‘solid’ Fages brings.

Burgess from a few years ago definitely but these days his lack of pace is pretty stark.
Gildart and Faz for me but after that nobody apart from maybe TL on the bench.
Pretty sobering

I think Burgess still has more to offer than Grace who I don’t really rate too highly.

Good going forward...that’s it.

LMS is playing better than Locky, sad to say as I’m Locky’s biggest fan but age has caught up with him.

Again I’m not slating Farrell but I don’t think he has hit the heights since he lost his England shirt. Good player but again at the moment i’d go with both Saints lads over him.

Tough to say as I love both players and detest Saints but at the moment they are light years ahead in nearly every department.

I am also a little shocked at how underrated Fages is. Much more consistent than Williams. When he is on I don’t doubt Williams is superior but sadly those “on” days are few and far between.

Farrell is a better second rower then anything Saints have. He’s been superb since he’s been back and would be immense in that Saints side.

LMS isn’t playing loose forward anyway and again Lockers has shown just how good he still is in some big games recently. I rate Morgan Knowles tbh but give me a focused Lockers any day.

Williams has 10 try’s and 12 assists to Fages 4 trys and 15 assists this season. He also has over a thousand more metres and about 50 more tackle busts. That’s on average form in a poor team, not in career best form in a team flying and playing behind the best front row (by more then a million miles) in superleague.

Saints are as good as they are because of the coach and the way he has the collective playing but it doesn’t make every player better then his opposite number in a struggling team.