But given their record so far either they never played like that before or we are not as good as other sides who have played them who can get past their tactics and defence.

It's one or the other and given our record this season I don't think it takes a genius to work out which one I reckon it is.

Dave

I scrolled up from the last post to this one and I didn't need to get to the top where I could see the user name to guess who posted it!

I have red several different opinions on the game and based on those Roberts was poor and for the 2nd week running was directly responsible for a try against us. Opinions on Riddell are at best divided (one good run was what I read elsewhere).

Doesn't matter because it isn't just one game is it? Time to realise some of our players are failing to deliver.

Dave

Celtic's home record before last night:

P6 W0 L6 D0 F84 A186 +/-(102) PTS0

Embarassing!

Which one was he directly at fault for? Their try that they scored from a kick on his wing wasn't his fault. I don't think the one they scored at the end was either.

Alex, they're bottom of the league for a very good reason. No matter how long they hold us down, no matter how much pressure they put on our halfbacks, if their coach is the referee and they're playing with a gale behind them and going down brew on a 1 in 5 gradient, we should not be losing to them.

Like I said on another thread, I've never really set my stall out on either side of the fence regarding Noble but I'm now starting to side with Jonh and DaveO. Noble is directly responsible for the way we play, the tactics we employ, the enthusiasm we have. It's his job to lift the team and he's not doing it.

Comparing us to Huddersfield there's probably only Hodgson (The fullback not the winger) who I'd definitely have in the Wigan team compared to there opposite number but they're 4th in the league, without a standoff. Who is that down to? They're probably a worse team on paper than they were last season yet they're now 4th. That's down to the coaching. Huddersfield, more than any team in SL, show what a difference a quality coach can make.

To quote John McClane:







[size=150"Welcome to the party pal". [/size

I totally agree that we were poor, we should not lose against Celtic Crusaders and the tactics laid down by Brian Noble were wrong but my summary is describing how the game went even if it doesn't fit in with previous expectations, stats or league positions. But it wasn't Wigan playing 'dreadful' and losing possesion on every set. Celtic earned the victory by setting out clever tactics against a superior team.

The players probably went into the game with the same attitude and expectations as some of our supporters which is another reason why we lost.

Fair do's

Who's to blame for that?

That is exactly how I feel. Before the game on Saturday me and my dad were all for giving Noble till the end of season, based on what he could do in certain games especially v Saints.

But after the result on Saturday we soon resided to the fact that it is time for Noble to go, time for a change, time for something different.

One of the things that annoys me is Noble pathetic excuses after the game. One he used on Saturday and used several times before is that we cant take these teams for granted and just assume 2 points are in the bag.

Surely this is the job of the coach to drill it in to the players heads not to take Celtic lightly, and to play at 100% like we did v Saints. Its not much to ask and it baffles me as to what they actually do in training each week

The supporters?

The players themselves & the coach.

Is the answer "the salary cap"?

It usually is on here.

I didn't need to guess who would be the 1st to try & get at Riddell/Roberts etc either DaveO



PS

This another thread where someone stands up to you & you disappear????

Oh and BTW! One good run I read somewhere is a selective Paraphrasing to say the least!

I have only looked this evening and found 3 or 4 claiming that Riddell going off & McCollorum coming on actually changed the game against us, a bit like last week if you ask me!

He was Very Good last week and Pretty good again this week, McCollorum on the hand was Poor last week and poor this week.
Does that not fit in with the agenda???

As for Roberts, I don't feel he was Singularly responsible for any of the tries yesterday, I was slightly disappointed he didn't hang on to the centre who made the break but coming 15 yards in off your wing whilst your 6 stands there and makes "No Effort" is far from being responsible for the try!

PS

As for McCollorum & Ainscough I don't get into "Bagging" them as I don't believe it's in anyones interest to do so (I think if you checkl any of my posts you will not find any Critical comments about either) just that I don't believe they are as good ATM as Riddell and Roberts.

Refering to the point the bottom for a good reason is unfair
they played well against leeds,saint
then went on to pick up a hell on a injury list yesterday im told aprt from 1 player that is the CC first choice squad and if they dont pick up anymore injuries i think it wont be the only 2 games they win
and before anyone has a go im a union guy who has watched them most home games and to be fair when they had 70% first team players out injuiered they where crap what now the almost back to full strength they can only get better

Same here. Spot on really, if anything I was more pro Noble than anything. Over three years, everything has changed, except Noble, we have new owners and new players, yet the same inconsistancy and lack of passion agianst so called lower clubs. Noble is the constant in all of that.

Go on, answer the points raised.



Which thread?

Dave

A couple of weeks ago you went off on the Roberts/Anscough debate, CBA looking but will do if you want proof!
You asked me 5 times on the same post for the same thing! I answered all the questions on why I thought Roberts ATM is a better choice than Ainscough and then guess what? Nothing!

I suppose if you ignore threads that go against your way of thinking then they go away eh????
If you continually post the same arguments then they must be true as well!

Regardless of all your positive comments towards the Celtic side, they possibly played the best they can. But it was still a NL1 standard performance from them.

Wigan should have had NO problems beating them and beating them with ease.

That dropped pass by Feka was abysmal. And he looks even more enormous. Someone at the club has to take of grip of his fitness or ship him out.

Correct. I didn't go yesterday but I passed comment on him at the Salford game. His condition is nothing short of appalling and is an indictment of not just himself but the club too.

Before the dropped ball, Feka was playing very well.

I don't care Alex. He needs to be disciplined for letting himself go in the way he has. If he played well yesterday, how good could he be? Let's face it, he is light years away from earning another Kiwi cap.