1 Tomkins 2 Charnley 3 Carmont 4 Atkins 5 Hall 6 Finch 7 Dureau 8 Hill 9 Roby 10 Casty 11 Westwood 12 Hock 13 O'Loughlin

Good to see Hill in there, hes been outstanding

I think they have got that team pretty spot on IMO. Only issue I may have is swap Carmont for Goulding.

Goulding has had a great season but Carmont has been simply outstanding all year. He hasn't played like a guy heading towards retirement.

Really wish he changed his mind and did another year.

*** Awaits comments from the Saints and Wire supporters who told me earlier this season that Carmont wasn't and had never been very good ***

just think how good Carmont would have looked and how many more assist/tries he would have had if Pat had been outside him for a further 10 games

they going mental on Facebook, how dare there be 6 Wigan players in the side, one idiot even suggested 1 player from each team so it would be fair another is questioning why there is no Paul wellens

I agree, I suppose its performances like we get from Carmont that we expect every game, whereas Goulding has really stepped up his performances this year.

Is that 3 years in a row now that Carmont has made the dream team?

I have to say I am surprised Carmont is in there too. Most of the other selections seem spot on although I would have probably had Leulaui instead of Dureau but his injuury probably counted against him.

Have you seen the Facebook post? It's pandemonium ha why can't they grasp that the best players are going to be at the best teams as its done on stats not votes?

Best one is the girl saying there should be one from every team.

14 teams but only 13 spots. Wow I really dont know how some people breathe.

3rd appearance in the Dream Team for Carmont, not 3 years in a row. My mistake!

Joel Monaghan should be in for Hall IMO but other then that I can't really argue.

The two props are very interesting choices (both correct as well). Hill has been a joy to watch coming from the championship to play at that level and Casty has reached a level I didn't think was possible a couple of years back. I always though he looked a bit small and pretty average but he's proved me wrong on both counts. He's all heart and aggression now.

The people on Facebook are too funny!

The majority of them want to see Wakefield players in there as they have been consistently performing well all season. Yet Wakefield finished 8th, the bottom half of the table!

This playoff system has made people dillusional...

Facebook certainly isn't the place for well thought out comments or any sort of reasoning, it's for the barely literate to mash their fists against a keyboard in furious indignation and it's all the more entertaining for it.

Basically, fans want the Dream Team to consist mainly of players from their club and think it shouldn't contain anyone from the team they hate the most.

So as a Wigan fan, this is what the Dream Team should have looked like...

1. Sam Tomkins (Wigan Warriors)
2. Josh Charnley (Wigan Warriors)
3. Darrell Goulding (Wigan Warriors)
4. George Carmont (Wigan Warriors)
5. Pat Richards (Wigan Warriors)
6. Brett Finch (Wigan Warriors)
7. Thomas Leuluai (Wigan Warriors)
8. Jeff Lima (Wigan Warriors)
9. Mike McIlorum (Wigan Warriors)
10. Lee Mossop (Wigan Warriors)
11. Harrison Hansen (Wigan Warriors)
12. Gareth Hock (Wigan Warriors)
13. Sean O'Loughlin (Wigan Warriors)

And anyone who disagrees is an absolute moron.

Enjoyed myself reading through those comments on the SL Facebook page, especially the ones that have an hatred and jealousy of anything associated with Wigan!

I had to laugh at one Wakey fan claiming that Tim Smith should be ahead of Finch and that Richard Agar should be 'Coach of the Year'.

All 6 fully deserve their spot in the team, the absence of Darrell Goulding suggests he is massively under rated by those "in the know" and should be equally credited for Chanrley's 30+ tries. The facebook comments are comedy gold, where have all these bitter Wakey fans come from?

Hall definitely deserves his place. Even 'playing poorly' and 'not ripping up any trees' in a 'mid table leeds side'according to the Wire board, he's scored 32 tries in all competitions, to Monaghan's 30 and Riley's 20. Only two ahead of him were Charnley & Tomkins (both with 35 tries IAC)

In 2005 I won a competition to be the 14th man in the Super LEague dream team. May be Tm Smith may be a competition winner



But can't argue with the team overall. Maybe if Tommy didn't have his injury and if Lima kept his form all season maybe he could have been considered for a prop space. But like I said couldn't really argue or disagree with the team.

No Goulding!!!! Disgrace

The Wellens comment on Facebook was the best and don't understand why people still think its Tompkins when its spelt correctly on what they're commenting about.

Facebook must be the latest craze in Wakey...

I'm pretty sure it is selected via votes from coaches.

Would certaintly have more credibility if it was chosen by the coaches, unfortunately........



which is why I'm always surprised at why people bitch and moan so much when xyz player hasn't been chosen.

I blame Gelling!

Sorry, couldn't resist. I'll get me coat...