Whats the verdict after his return

A couple of errors, but a solid run out after such a long lay off. Made some really good defensive reads but fell off a few tackles- as to be expected.

Thought did pretty well tbh.

A couple of errors - but Some really good defensive reads. Made the right side and edge look much better.

Liked that he was shouting at some of our players when they misread plays. He is 100% Giants. Need more of his passion and commitment to our relegation battle.

went well , been a big miss!

love the tackles by grabbing the collar

gets them down time and time again

Poor, still does not tackle, always side steps an attacking player to jump on his back

There was nothing wrong with the collar grab as such but it’s poor RL. It’s basically a last ditch effort with a 50/50 chance of working. How many times do you see players break through these grabs, a lot. Also how often do they wrongly get called as high tackles, a lot.

It’s a failure to tackle properly imho but it can be effective occasionally.

He's not fit, clearly.
Its gonna take him a while to get back, I think this game should have been a 40 for him tbh.

it’s often an attempt of his to effect a tackle when someone inside him has missed one and the opposition player is about to break through.

get them down time and time again, its a tackle and hes a master of it