Possible link to us here: www.skysports.com/story/0,19528, ... 91,00.html Can't see if myself - we've other priorities I would have thought?

Possible link to us here: www.skysports.com/story/0,19528, ... 91,00.html Can't see if myself - we've other priorities I would have thought?

I hope he is not connected to us. Too slow for the backs and not as good as our other back row forwards. Cannot see it myself

That was my thinking DG - just seems at the moment we get linked with just about everyone going.

er no thank you !

To All, a fantastic player that can create something out of nothing. Maybe getting on a bit now but if available for the right value, then I would personally snap him up as a squad player

A fantastic player who is sadly passed his best

however i would still take him on

WHY????

''''''simples my dear meerkats''''''''

to help develop the young backs that we have already got and give the benefit of his vast experience and quality, maybe as a player / coach

I believe that the reinvolvment of drewy in the club has developed our key influence players and i could see the beaver doing it here

Who will be 37 and looking for a big wadge to come here. Money which would be spent on a top player who could come here for 3 or 4 years or alternatively 3 or 4 young players who could be tied to the club as they develop

Durham Giant, you would be wrong regarding Steve Menzies being able to command a large salary. You would probably be wrong regarding a lot of players' salaries in all honesty.

I would like to offer you one as a starting point but it would be wrong of me to do so

I don't think he would be able to demand a high salary, the problem for me is I think he would be a waste of an oversea's spot.

I would gues only the club and players know what everyone is on but i doubt that Menzies would be on less than the likes of Brown, Mcgilvaray and Carlisle put together.

I would rather any money spent on Menzies be used to keep LUNT.

Gilmour would do as good or better job at centre and o'Donnell and Fa alogo will be better at second row. It would be silly IMHO to use salary cap and a quota space to sign a 37 year old

Durham Giant, I do not like your way of thinking but I can see where you are coming from. Shaun Lunt is only worth so much, to break current club tradition and give him a contract that he does not deserve, just to keep him, would be wrong. Shaun Lunt has already stated he would like to play in Australia at the end of his current contract and more than likely will do. Huddersfield Giants have an excellent replacement for Shaun Lunt in Kyle Wood.

=#FF0000Agree



I would agree about Lunt if he is wanting more than the club feel he is worth then let him go BUT i would much rather spend any money that would have been spent on Menzies be used to to either bring in a =#FF0000quality first team player to the squad or to develop younger players who will stay with the Giants in the longer term.

If Menzies is a second row he would surely be behind . Fa alogo, O Donnell, Patrick , Kimond. Not counting any other second rows we may be linked with.

If he was to play centre he would be behind Lawrence, Gilmour, Cudjoe. ( partly based on criteria of homegrown and academy players etc) not counting trying to sign Quinn etc.

I do not see Menzies playing any other positions


Surely we would only sign Menzies as a squad player and i cannot see Menzies wanting to sign on squad players salary.

I'd be happy to look at Beever.

Anyone would be happy to look at Beever.

He's not to be sniffed at.

Despite his age he is one of the fittest players in Super League and one of the top 5 back rowers in the league. The man is pure quality and a very good signing for any team.

cant see the point in signing menzies weve just let a player in wild go who is 8 years younger and imo a better player at this time in both players careers because weve got an abundance of 2nd rowers cant see it happening to be honest.

Takes some licking too

There's a rumour going around that the Karate kid himself Fa alogo might be coming back down under to play for the Cronulla Sharks.

hope not, faalogo class when fully fit

he owes us to stay after being out so much of the season!