Now is the time for Brown to make some changes in the team. I would like to see players playing for the places and accepting that second best is not good enough.

For Salford i would like to see

Hodgson B

Leroy
Fatz
Brown
Bruno

Fulton
Robinson

Jacko
Moore
Mason
Raleigh
Lolesi
Wild


Crabtree
Griffin
Lunt
Finnegan

Fulton to run the plays, Robbo given a free role to cause mayhem, and a bench full of pace attacking plays.

All players told they have to perform or are dropped for the next game. with Hodgson, Moore and Griffin particularly put under the spotlight.

Sounds bob on to me

B. Hodgson and Moore particularly need a kick after Friday night.

Would prefer to see Mossop on the bench in place of Griffin or Finnigan.

I don't think Moore did much wrong.

Took some very wrong options, and their first try came directly from teh field position he gave them from a terrible kick.

despite him being revered by most giants fans,im getting worried by brett hodgson, a fine player no doubt but his mistakes are costing us games ( well the last 2) would he be brave enough to drop brett in place of leroy who has been fairly solid?

for me he has to find some pace in the backs,last few games have shown we are struggling with pacy backs, i would also get crabtree back on the bench where he can cause destruction, finnegan hasn't done a right lot to impress me either lately.

my team would be

B hodgson

cudjoe
wild
whatuira
D hodgson

brown
robinson

mason
moore
mossop

raleigh
lolesi
fulton

crabtree
sculthorpe
fauimu
lawrence

Agree re Brett Hodgson he has to cut out the stupid mistakes in attack. His defencive position is still world class though.
I also agree the lack of pace in the outside backs is a problem but just as bad is the lack of a steadying influence at half back to calm the team down and generally make the right decisions.

I still think our forwards are as good as any in the competition though. The likes of Mason Crabtree Raleigh Kirmond Wild Finnigan Jackson have hardly put a foot wrong this season. Now we have added mossop who looks quality and Sculthorpe who has his faults but his offloading potential offers so much in attack as he showed in glimpses on friday. We have massive strength in depth in the forwards with another world class second rower wrriving next year.
Recruitment for next season has to be based on improving the backs.

I'd also say we have perhaps some of the best centres in the game too, certainly Fatz shows his class week in and week out, Lawrence at centre is top notch and ever improving, add to that the likes of Wild, Brown and Jammer and we have some real class and depth.

Wingers are a problem, especially with Hodgy and Aspers playing poorly (that said Hodgy was solid as a rock in defence, its attach he is lacking at the moment)

As or Fullback, Cudjoe is superb and getting better each time he plays I think, Bret is excellent in defence positionally, but weak in the tackle.

Bret's main failing is his attempts to join the attack as another halfback, on Friday thats when we got thrown into confusion, and too many times now his passes have been plucked off, but that might be down to the rest of the team being too flat - and lacking dummy runners, something we had in spades early doors.

I agree. Brett tries things, we need that. Still a quality player. But forwards didn't get enough go forward on Friday.

We need a playmaker with some composure who can take on the line in his own right. Unfortunately they are like goldust.
Brett Hodgson is a class act. He may have made a few mistakes but that won't stop him tryng things 'cos he's still got the confidence in his own ability. If Luke Robinson can show half his composure we'd be rocking. How anybody can break the line with one man to beat and options on both sides and still cock it up is beyond me.
We missed Andy Raleigh from the start and Danny Kirmond - they give 100% 100% of the time.
We've got a great set of forward's but the real calss acts are Fatz and Brett Hodgson with Liam Fulton showing good signs.
Lawrence and Cudjoe are improving and I'd like to bet that's down to Fatz and Brett.
Let's face it, the Aussie's and Kiwi's are still street's ahead as shown in the world cup and that's reflected at the Giants.
I still think we can finish 3rd, but to do that we've got to stop the errors and start putting a bigger percentage of the chances away. It might seem obvious but that's what separates the winners from the also rans.
Let's start at Salford...............

I was thinking about Brett Hodgson and i think a lot of his problem is he is tring too much. he is trying to play as an extra half back in attack possibly because Nathan Brown does not really rate the ones we have.

If we had a world class half back who dictated play (hopefully next seaon) Hodgson could stop the plymaking role and concentrate more on making and supporting breaks which is surely were his strength lies.

Yeah, he is at his best when he joins the line or acts as a ball handling centre, when he is at 1st or 2nd man, then his standards fail a bit.

Squads announced NO RALEIGH



Salford City Reds squad

Wilshere, Henry, Walton, Turner, Stapleton, Smith, Myler, Cashmere, Alker, Jewitt, Sibbit, Sidlow, Swain, Goulding, Littler, Leuluai, Adamson, Ratchford, Paul.



Huddersfield Giants squad

B. Hodgson, Brown, Whaturia, D. Hodgson, Fulton, Robinson, Crabtree, Faiumu, D. Griffin, Wild, Finnigan, P. Jackson, Mason, Lawrence, Moore, Cudjoe, Lunt, Mossop, Sculthorpe.

NO JAMMER EITHER

From the squad i would go with :

B.Hodgy

Leroy
Fatz
Bruno
D.Hodgy

Brown
Robbo

Jacko
Moore
Mason

Wild
Mossop
Fulton

subs:

Eorl
Griffin
Faimu
Finnigan

Leroy at FB for me.

Where would you put Brett Hodgson?

Was speaking to his ,mum after the game and he got a knock on his knee again on Friday and was always going to be a doubt for this week.

Myler facing a late fitness test ahead of the game

Think we can safley say Ritchie has played his last game in a Salford shirt!!

Warrington bound?

'Rest' him.