if you are looking at top quality oversses players i would add
John Skandalis
Dave Atkins
Ben Roarty

Atkins. Love him. 50 tackles a game no bother and god knows how many metres. Hardest working player I've ever seen in a giants shirt. (Followed by adey toole- 90 minute prop and smoked up to 40 a day according to Ben Barton! He may have been pulling my leg!)

Rocket Rod Jensen would be in my top 10 - probably before Wild. Rod was electric to watch and a real fans favourite.

I meant dave atkins not lomax, agree about roarty, class act but didn't do it for long enough for me to warrant a place, same goes for Jensen, 12 games I think he played?

Anyone remember Albert Torrens? Only played 7 games for us, but scored 5 tries, including one in the last min to beat Wakey, could have been a real susperstar

Rod jenson had pace- but didn't offer anything else- and oh how BAD was he at fullback!
Torrens was a class act- just unlucky with a bad injury-- he wanted to stay but according to what he told me was treated pretty shoddily by the giants.

I would certainly have Chris Nero in the top 10, very strong player both in attack and defence. Mr reliable, a really reliable, classy player for us.

certainly deserves a mention...not far from being in the top 10...with wild and kev brown these really did bring the Giants a long way

Cannot believe Dean Hanger wasn't in the top ten, up there with Stanley for the X factor
Shame Wally Gibson was a bit before the super league he'd have been difficult to leave out

hangar was a key player before our super league days, I think he only played one season in super league era?
certainly a crowd pleaser and one of the best players I've seen in a fartown shirt, but not one of the top 10 in SL era.

Julian Bailey

what ever happened to Julian Bailey? he was a brilliant centre for us!

went back down under I believe, not spectacular but a good solid player for us at the time and did a very good job.

liked him but hardly in the top 10 super league players we have ever had is he. prob put him behind whatuira, cudjoe and evans just for the centre spots

Plus Wardle Nero de vere and Lolesi. In fact he would struggle to make the top 10 centres

If he stayed fit then Albert Torrens would be somewhere close to the top 10.

maybe , shame he only got 7 games with us!

I absolutely loved Torrens in those games, i even got my shirt printed and singed by the man. I will never forget when he ran over the top of Henry Fa'afili, which at the time i thought was unbelievable.... but then 10 minutes later Ben Cooper did it too and spoilt it a bit.

I actually did laugh out loud at this

it was a great moment!

If LOD had stayed fit and not left, i think on his day he was one of the best forwards in the league. he had class, mongrel and carried the pack on many occasions.

Shame we didn't have hint and fielded at the back end of last year, it could have been a different story

Perhaps if his pal hadn't been treated so badly he would of stayed!

very good shout! made a massive difference on the field

a recent fans vote of chris roberts selections ... in order

Danny Brough
Brad Drew
Eorl Crabtree
Brett Hodgson
Stanley Gene
Bradon Costin
Paul Reilly
Chris Thorman
Danny Russell
Bobbie Goulding


danny brough wins... agree too, drew number 2? not for me.

not many rated goulding then!

probably because not many saw him play for us, plus the fact that both he and russell played in poor teams probably wont mark them out as standout players, they were both very good players but in terms of impact they had on the team they werent very noticable.