To be fair we were missing a number of key players - Brough, Mcgillvary, Leroy, Mamo, Leeming, Roberts. Any team struggles without their key players.

Nope you are wrong. Ken Davy, Richard thewlis and three successive coaches say that - not me.

Ok jools you are right as usual, sorry, thewlis is not an issue it was sharp then brown then Anderson then Stone now thorman, spot on

So not ken Davy then?

You forgot mall Reilly, van de velde, John kear ... oh wait Richard wasn’t even MD at the club then.....

Ken Davy is allowing the slide, how he can be happy with thewlis is mind boggling, so many big decisions wrong for so long, but hey you keep believing in him I for one have had enough

It’s not just the quality of the first team that’s sliding.

Losing to a side as hopeless as Catalan shows not everything was the fault of Rick Stone. He's gone and things are not exactly improving as Giants fans said would happen when he was handed his p45.

The supporters got behind them Friday because they played with some determination and guts when clearly on paper their pedigree was nowhere near the Rhinos

Today was a disgrace and a betrayal of fans who spent their earnings travelling out there to support hoping for at least a repeat showing that would get them up to 8th position after a poor start . The senior players showed no leadership and example to the young lads thrown to a team made up mainly of seasoned pros and looked to have absolutely no rhythm or game plan .

At least someone should have introduced them to each other before they got on the plane
What a complete waste of a pilots time and fuel!

Frankly the horizon of hope looks a very long way away Forget the injury justification Professional players paid to do their job should at least have some personal pride but no evidenceof it on that showing . Still Mac should at least be grateful !

Thewlis is an utter disaster no area of the club is moving forward on his watch and anyone who thought appointing Thorman and keeping the same cosy set up was the way forward had a rude awakening today. Only Ken knows why he continues to put his trust in someone who is not up to managing a professional club

What position do Thewlis and Thorman play? The way I see it they would not have played as bad as the team who played at the Catalans.

It’s not about 1 result or performance it’s the structure and ethos of the whole set up that needs changing.

There is supposedly an invitation to coaches to apply for the job going out. Now if i were a coach or indeed any coach who is worth a light , he will research the job and the club very carefully before he applies.

What he will find is a club that has been in the wilderness for more years than he has probably been alive, Had more coaches than he has had hot dinners and so little success that you couldn't make it up.

Fair enough up till 25 years or so ago that applied to most of , if not all of the Rugby league right up to Summer rugby starting and the injection of Sky money. With the help of Mr Davy and his money the Giants got into the top club and with the exception of a few seasons you could count on one hand ( almost exclusively down to N Brown ) nothing has changed, the club has not moved forward one inch in real terms, it survives on Sky money supported by Mr Davy's money, Crowds never grow because ( in my opinion ) they either want to see a winning team, of they want to see decent Football for more than an odd game now and then, so at Huddersfield they lose out on both counts.

So what any prospective coach see's is in affect, A club that has gone nowhere for a long time and shows no sign of doing so anytime in the forsee able future, why would any coach of any note want to get enmeshed with a club like that. It comes over as a losers club from the very top downwards.

You do get the odd coach from nowhere ( as it were ) T Smith, Nathan Brown , etc but they are few and far between, so you either make the job very lucrative to attract the top men, or you go down the well travelled route of a lesser coach and expensive has been's and semi crippled players.

Somewhere out there is the man who can do the job, and if we were talking Saints, Leeds, Wigan etc they would leave no stone unturned until they found him, Sadly it doesn't work like that at the Giants They seem to get to keep dipping their bread in the Gravy no matter how badly the club staggers, so they will continue to bump along the bottom with endless more false dawns, and with the emergence of Toronto Toulouse etc , the lower divisions look nailed on in the near future.

hang on i thought everything was all rosy again after the point against leeds???? all rick stones fault

What we need more than anything else is a coach who is smart. Yes he'll have to have all the other attributes required but most of all he'll need to be smart. Why do we have so many first choice players out for long periods of time? Probably because the last couple of coaches have played injured players instead of being smart and rested him and bringing in a non injured second stringer as cover. Now we're in a position where 9/10 players are out long-term and we're recalling players from loan and playing 17 year olds. Not even the likes of Wigan, Saints or Rhino's would be winning games with that amount out. I didn't think we could be as unlucky with injuries again this season but here we are again. Why?

Grandad

Is it all down to luck, or are there other reasons, I would hope that is the first question any prospective new coach would ask.

It’s all down to cheap.
We have a completely inexperienced “head” of conditioning. Way out of his depth.
He was promoted to the job because the previous guy quit as he couldn’t do things as he wished due to lack of money.
When he asked for proper footwear for the players to wear the club wouldn’t pay - I would imagine ha I g the proper gear is one way of reducing injuries.....

That sounds about right or at least there has to be something more than three years of bad luck.

Any news or rumours who ya new coach might be or if the have started to look into who they would like?

nope.

thorman.

Well Thorman seems to have a handle on our issues. He knows where the problems lie and is looking to do something about it.
The new appointment in the strength and conditioning department looks like he has the full backing of the board too!

Would you and the other Giants fans approve/accept Thorman as the new head coach ?

Thorman would be the cheap safe option so will suit our ethos I suspect he will get the job and I wish him all the best

we got the emotional reaction against leeds we wanted to see, but will that wear off

the jury is still out, far too early to say yes give him the job

but limited what he can do with the injuries we currently have anyway!!

before the season started i said top 6 finish IF we avoided the injuries... but its happened so now its all about survival in sl for 2018

Thewlis idea for bumper, chris knew nothing about it but as previous coaches he will take he blame or credit if it weilds results, thewlis signs players and hires staff, sooner you realise that the score owner tou will realise it doesn’t matter who coaches us he gets the players thewlis gives him

on two of the last three performances thorman gets the job

players are playing for him with the enthusiasm, today again at half time he said he had to tear strips off them to get a reaction and says its shouldnt take that!!! same in training too