Quote ="Magic Superbeetle"Here you go: www1.skysports.com/watch/video/t ... was-brough?'" Inconclusive from the angles and St Helens players all offside when charging down the attempts says john kear

Quote ="Magic Superbeetle"Here you go: www1.skysports.com/watch/video/t ... was-brough?'" Inconclusive from the angles and St Helens players all offside when charging down the attempts says john kear

There has been a few fans saying it didn't go over from behind the sticks.
There must be at least 1 Huddersfield fan that had a good enough angle and admit it didn't go over?

Regards to the guy who said Ferres shouldn't be banned. I think you are thinking of a different incident in a different game and a different sport from another country.
In fact I think you may have posted on the wrong forum.

As expected then all the 'it was definitely was a drop goal' people are sticking to their guns or just staying silent, despite being shown that it was not a drop goal or at best inconclusive.

A far cry from a dead cert drop goal.

I'm sure now the question has been answered the chairman may want to write another letter. But then to be fair they are not known for changing their minds over on this side of the hills. For Stubbornness see Bulls signing Harris, Huddersfield sacking Mason

Is this still going????? ZZzzzzzzz

You say ZZzzzzzzz, but keep coming back?

Just cos I'm surprised you are all still whinging about it

? Are we? Or is it just us responding to the many trolls that seem to be diving out from under their bridges? Must be troll breeding season.

Here's a tip then - don't respond!

The Chairman, as far as i know, hasn't commented on it, he certainly hasn't wrote any letters !!

All?

its ok when its not your team

Shelley .....you need to get a life....

So Bentham is right and all those calling him a cheat or a thief look silly, gutting if it's your team but it was ultimately the right decision.

I've got a quite nice one really, but thanks for the ill informed advice







Now

Anyone else notice Cas get penalised for offside last night when no off side player made a tackle?
They just make it up as they go along don't they!!!!!

That's par for the course, nothing new or strange about Saints being awarded imaginary penalties by inept refs.

A week as passsd and nothings changed
Upset supporters -trolls deranged
The refs in charge

result still stands
The match reult is out of our hands
So lets move on to our next game
Same old refs - its all the same
Lets hope the lads pull out the stops
For t`rest of season and we finish tops

Overall,whilst annoying last weekend - I think this has run its course and its time to move on
Result stands and always would -end of!

jools,
do you understand the offside rule

sorry mate I will rephrase that!
Jools you obviously don't understand the offside rule

Shows an astute brain when you answer your own question!

Thank you Micky --now back in your cot!

Your right I don't - because in the same week we have had two completely different interpretations of the offside rule- Which offside rule is it going to be next week? the offside rule that allows Cas to be penalised for being offside when the offside players were not interfering in play, or the one which we were told by head idiot that saints didnt need to penalised for being offside as the offside players weren't interfering in play?
Or will it be some other rubbish they make up to cover up the fact that they make glaring errors?

interfering with play can be effecting which way the attacking team decide to play, that's down to the ref to decide if the offside bloke has caused that decision to be made.
To penalise or not will also depend on which bit of the park the play is as well, in the red zones should always be pinged, in the middle of the park normally they will let it run
Who is the head idiot you are talking about by the way.
however name any team that are ever onside on there own goal line?, big whit line to help em and still cant do it.
crackerjack thanks for the input mate, you missed the fact I was re phrasing not restating a comment

We were told last week by Ganson that the reason saints were not penalised by being for offside at the drop goal attempts because they didn't interfere in play! Garbage! For the reasons in your first paragraph. They trot out this "interpretation" line to cover up the fact that the refs are consistently inconsistent!

Move on guys, this thread is like Miracle-Gro for the trolls.