Is he likely to be back soon, do we know?

Its a niggling injury, the club are still trying to get him in for full treatment on it.

Can't see what it matters now unless we get injuries in our backline, pownall and maden got to be first choice , he for me is 4th choice winger at least

Cheers for the info Dave. Hope he can get it sorted soon.

I must admit , in my oppinion that is , i would have Maden , Pownall , and Clay in front of him .

That's fair enough and I am not saying I disagree, but he is still OUR player and it was starting to feel like he had never played for us. Just wondered how he was doing, as hadn't read or heard owt. Plus, we will always have injuries and suspensions, players showing lack of form etc.

Hope he is back soon. He drives the ball in well as does Maden and gives our forwards a breather.

Charlie is clueless.

Maden drives a ball harder than Half our props. Top player

So one does one does not ? Which is which ?

Having said that lobby without carrots is so stuck in a time warp.

He was out during the pre warm up on Friday

Must admit I haven't been to a lot of games due to work commitments but last year he looked to be a stand out player and the crowd seemed lifted when he starts scooting from dummy-half.

And being his sponsor I obviously have another reason to wanting him back soon...

I'm a big fan of McGilvary. Really hard working, solid in defence too.

me too

YES , but would you put him in front of Maden , Pownall , and Clay ?I know i wouldnt .

Most definately in front of clay.
Maddens on the other wing so not really relevent.
That leaves him battling with pownall and as we know theres nowt wrong with healthy competition

John , i feel Clay hasnt been given a chance yet to show what he can do , given the chance i think he will shine , McGilvary is Nicky Stanton with another head on

, he tries to burrow underneath the opposition ,or bust through them and he isnt big enough .

AScored two belting tries against Salford first game, got pace and can tackle, as I said I like him , Pownall is a FB really, so maybe we should move Mcnally to 7, Johhny to 1 and Duffs/nicho to 9, deano to number 5, beswick 13

I agree with duffs to 9 but theres no way we can move McNally. Apart from his mess up against york he's been solid at FB and he runs straight

Agree there mate your spot on with that. am all for movin players if it improves the team but movin players just to accommodate deano no thanks he makes more yards goin backwards or to the side with the occasional yard forward, sure the same people liked Stanton as well where is he playing again now lol.

Other wing what does that matter, so what your sayin is we only got maden for one wing and rest for the other?

Maden is secure,no one is going to take his place unless he's injured or needs to go to centre.
why you two keep comparing Mcgillvary to stanton is beyond comprehension,mcgillvary is miles more effective

Swinton probably

Pownall and Maden have been playing really well so they've earned their place in the team. But if we run into injuries in the backs it's nice to have two wingers of Clay and McGilvrays quality to back up.

Pownall is a Fullback and Maden played well in the centres pre season, it's a long time since we had 4 good wings.

Why oh why do some still insist on bagging our own players in public some of you really do need to revisit the dictionary and look up the words supporter and fan (fanatic).

Who's bagging them?