I don't usually have a go at match officials as they have a hard enough job as it is, but having reviewed both last nights and last Fridays Widnes V Oldham dvd's, how this guy has another top game this weekend is beyond me, he was clearly influenced by the crowd last night, he was inconsistent in BOTH games in the way he gave the penalties not only against the two winning teams but against both losers.
His performances over the last two games should be shown to young refs as how not to ref a game.
No sour grapes on the main 'event' as Hobson clearly showed intent even if he didnt connect (inconclusive on dvd, and as for another post the Fev fan who said the player jumped straight up, well yes he did once Mr Childs reached for the red card as he went down as if he'd been shot from the 'grassy knoll' but the yellow card for Stewart, yes he's not the most quickest of players geting off the tackle but he had let far slower ones get away completely unpunished.
Sorry Mr Childs but your evaluation last night would have been 1/10 and that would be for just turning up.

Do the club have the opportunity to put a report in on the officials?
It would be interesting to see what both Leigh and Widnes had to say about him.

reports are made by every club at all ages on the referee its a form called the referees assesment form, its pretty standard at most age groups.

Now removed from NWC 13-15 official team sheet.

Refs not rated/comments not asked for anymore

What he said.



I will not watch another match where he is the ref

I should have known that as Im on the discipline commitee for that age group



** note to myself... wake up you dozy burger...



Must see about having it re implemented

I must say i was fuming after the Oldham game with some of his decisions, it was almost as if he had been payed a lofty sum just to punish us.


Thus my disappearance for 24hrs, i was that livid.

Well after watching the DVD, it was awful reffing. 18 6 I made the count in Fev s favour.
Hobbo incident from the angle the film shows didnt look as if it warrented a straight red, the Fev player desrved an oscar the way he fell to the floor.
Stewart did lay on, but no more then a few of their players had, he certainly didnt persistantly lay on as people have slated him for. He was unfortunate to be yellow carded IMHO.As for the REfs display it seems worse on the DVD than when there.

God help Fax Sunday.
Hope they save Mr Childs For Mr Lewis new favourites.

Dick. If Tommy Haughey's fall to the ground was contrived - I'd say so! I never try and make anything of an issue that I perceive as objective fact.
I'm too old and long in the tooth for that now.
But the incident with Hobson happened right in front of me and he collared Haughey good and proper. His head recoiled to his left as he was taken to the head. The ref showed the red straight away and Tommy got up in a matter of seconds.
Fred:- Tommy was running full tilt and was taken out to the left temple if my memory serves me correct. He went down and got straight up. He was getting up regardless of what the ref was doing - who was very quick with the card!!!
If Tommy was guilt of feigning or milking an injury - I'd soddin well say so and criticise him for it!!!! He wasn't!! Hobson did NOT miss!
Hiowever, the ref was still sheeite!

Yeah right, Nowt to do with you losing then

But Im not going off memory im going off video evidence which is better? im not saying Hobson didnt deserve it as the intent was there, but the Fev player reaction was a bit OTT not that any other player wouldn't do the same just stating a fact, and thats something you cant argue against.

The fact that RL isn't cheap anymore means there has to be a competant man in the middle. I only had to read one post about this ref and I knew what you meant, he was a shambles last Friday and obviously a shambles on Wednesday.

People pay £15-£20 to go watch a rugby game they shouldn't have a referee thinking everyones come to see him.

exactly

At the end of the day , if you dont rate the refs

Ave a go yourself





I did , I was accused by a certain person named Millward as being the worst they had ever seen



And no it wasn't Roger

In all honesty they go into a profession/hobby knowing they `re going to get slated by one set of fans.......Pseudo SM fans......

When both sets of fans or parents say a ref s bad he must be

Not necessarily they`re just being fans/parents.........

Rather than criticise the ref (even if he was cr@p) I though the object of the exercise is not to give the ref an opportunity to make cr@p decisions. Hobson clearly did and he will remain a liability as long as he plays.

I think some are losing the point no one has/had any qualms about the sending off of Hobson its the refs overall performance thats at question.

Bad day at the office

Very very very bad day

its quite simple, hobson was a bad buy, i said so at the time and i say so now, as for the ref last night, yes he was awful, and i hate and i repeat hate slagging off refs, but lets not take anyhting away from a truely awesome performance from our boys, yes we lost, but we will play far worse this year and win.