As we've reached the end of the regular season, I thought it might be a good point to see peoples thoughts on the players this year and compare improvements or not.

Maybe marks out of ten so far.

Ratch - 8
Lineham -7
Goodwin - 6.5
King - 7 ( I think he will now kick on)
Josh - 8
Brown -7
Tyrone - 6
Hill - 7
Clark - 10
Cooper -10
Hughes - 8.5 (most of what he does goes unnoticed by the haters)
Livett - 7
SBW - 9 (taking into account his age he should get a 10)

Philbin - 7.5
Sita - 6
Atkins - 7
Ben MM - 7
G King - 6
Dec - 7

Haters? Many people thought he wasn't playing well in 2017, and he wasn't. I don't think anyone professed to "hate" him. Solid in 2018.

With 21 tries in a part season so far Josh surely is a 10?

Just looking at "Fatbelly's" response. The one that stands out for me is Bryson Goodwin.
I think he's a really strong performer. Very tough and a handful most weeks.

Ratchford - 8
Lineham - 8
Goodwin - 7
T King - 7
Charnley - 10
K Brown - 7
Roberts - 5
Hill - 8
Clark - 10
Cooper - 9
Livett - 8
Hughes - 8
Westwood - 9

Philbin - 8
Aukola - 6
BMM - 7
Patton - 7
G King - 6
Atkins - 6
M Brown - 7
Pomeroy - 7
Smith - 6

Ratchford - 8
Lineham - 8
Goodwin - 7
T King - 7
Charnley - 10
K Brown - 7
Roberts - 5
Hill - 8
Clark - 10
Cooper - 10
Livett - 8
Hughes - 8
Westwood - 9

Philbin - 8
Aukola - 5
BMM - 7
Patton - 5
G King - 6
Atkins - 7
M Brown - 7
Pomeroy - 7
Smith - 6

I think 5 is a tad harsh on Roberts but I understand it. I have a sneaky feeling by the end of the season he'll be around the 9 mark for most people and we'll bemoan him leaving....think he may regret it too.

Ratchford - 9
Lineham - 8
Goodwin - 8
T King - 8
Charnley - 10
K Brown - 6
Roberts - 7
Hill - 8
Clark - 10
Cooper - 9
Livett - 7
Hughes - 8
Westwood - 8

Philbin - 7
Aukola - 6
BMM - 7
Patton - 6
G King - 6
Atkins - 7
M Brown - 6
Pomeroy - 6
Smith - 6

Roberts hadn't done himself any NRL prospecting favours by being poor in our league...however he can showcase himself into an NRL contract by the end of the month.
I still believe he'll get the Lance Todd.

Ratchford - 8
Lineham - 8
Goodwin - 7
T King - 7
Charnley - 9
K Brown - 6.5
Roberts - 5
Hill - 8
Clark - 9.5
Cooper - 9
Livett - 7
Hughes - 8
Westwood - 8

Philbin - 8
Aukola - 6
BMM - 7
Patton - 7.5
G King - 5
Atkins - 6
M Brown - 7
Pomeroy - 7
Smith - 6

Hey Moving on... how do you get a 10 under your schema? Would Brian Bevan have got one?

I actually think that's why he's started kicking for us. Wants to get his numbers up, plus showing he's a decent GK will do him no harm in getting a deal back home.

Not complaining, he was great on Sunday, so keep it up I say!

Struggling to see why some people have given Morgan Smith higher ratings than Tyrone Roberts...Has he been ripping it up somewhere else. Dec Patton as a half would be a 5 but as a Hooker he would get a 7.

Generally over the season so far I would say we are a smattering of 7s and 8s. Josh has been a breath of fresh air with his attitude and enthusiasm. I still think he has a ways to go before its a 10.

I was once told to never give a 10. 10/10 is a perfect score and no one is perfect.

I honestly just searched trough our squad list to see who SBW was



I was thinking “the only SBW I know is Sonny Bill” haha


I’d say:
Ratchford 8
Lineham 7
Goodwin 7
TKing apart from one poor half which seems to have stuck in my mind and it shouldn’t, he’s been very good and I’d like him to keep his place now 7
Charnley, what a signing! 9
KBrown 6
Roberts 6
Hill 7
Clark, what a player! 9
Cooper, back to his St George best! 9
Hughes 7
Livett, I’ll be honest I’m not massively keen on him 6
Westwood 8
Philbin 8
Akauola 5
Murdoch-Massila 7
GKing 6
Patton 6
Atkins 7
MBrown 5