How on earth is Rhys Evans still in the squad? Offers nothing in attack and is absolutely shambolic in defence!!!

Streuth

I'm guessing sarcasm...

Likewise...

Token welsh-y.

No problem with Rhys at the moment. Had the best "Average Gain" for anyone in the Saints game. No errors & only 1 missed tackle

ONe swallow does not make a summer and a large part of the meter gain would have been from where Russell put him through, as he should do for Russell on a weekly basis

His stats over a season are poor assists n try's very low for a team with ambitions of gf success. They are more what one would expect from a side in the bottom half of the table ..... ohhh wait a minute !!!!

I did say "No problem with Rhys at the moment" Livett will take his place on Sunday. This will be his last season as I can see him going back to South Wales & playing union.

The really staggering thing about Sunday was that pass from Russell. He has shown absolutely no inclination or ability to pass a ball never mind one as good as that. Gobsmacked.

From an outsider's perspective he's rubbish. offers nothing in attack and his defence isn't great. I hope you extend his contract and continue to play him

You mean you've not hear the rumour that he is on his way to hull and fauna on his way to us plus 150k Fanua was so desperate for the deal that he is playing his first and last year of his two year contract free of charge and will be cycling to warrington as part of his comute and commitment to help create a greener planet !!

"The really staggering thing about Sunday" was the way he ran through the opposition like they weren't even there.

fauna? You're more likely to sign flora

He signed for leigh for next season

Missing him already, not

TIme is probably right for him to move on, he's always been ok without tearing up trees, which is a shame as coming through the ranks he had huge promise.

Good luck to him, hopefully his injuries clear up, at his age now he really needs to be a regular starter, which at a club with aspirations of top 4, I don't think he is.

I can't ever really knock his effort, so he deserves to go with a decent rep.

Now confirmed on the website, he has signed for Leigh for 2018

Could not see anything there about Russell going with him

Never kicked on from his promise as a youngster. Not helped by being made of biscuit.

I am expecting

Gidley
Sims
Dywer
Westwood
Wilde

to follow next

First team debut in 2010?! Such a shame he never really cracked on.

It's a pity, but as we all know he simply didn't seem to progress that much apart from his defence.

Is there a trend with young 'promising' players that rely on one main strength ? The big 17 yr old forward that can run through his smaller counterparts, but never really learns to use his feet or make use of his arms to fend off the opposition - simply because he doesn't need to. The speedster that can run around the opposition line but who struggles to break the line when he gets into the 1st team. I think Rhys was perhaps one of these type of players. He only had one sidestep to use to get past a player, and never used his hands and arms to fend off tacklers.

Anyway, good luck to him, earning your living in sport is tough business.

Good luck to Rhys. The last Welshman in our team. I have been watching Wires for over 50 years now & I can't remember a team without at least 1 Welshman.

Stormed it in service area, both him and Ben did. A long way to the top mind. Shame.

Injuries are a cruel Mistress.

Wish him all the best. As said by most already, didn't seem to progress attacking-wise after such early promise. Maybe that was the injuries.

Begs the question though, seeing as though we are happy to let him go why did he seem to be Smith's darling for the centre/wing spots even when clearly out of form? Were we really that short of options at the time? Is Smith's influence waning?

I wish we could have a poll every week to get a feel of the people's thoughts on whether Smith should stay or go, just like the election run-up polls.