So let me get this straight, Cummings thinks there is absolutely nothing wrong with Manfredi doing exactly the same thing that Atkins was penalised for last week [i twice[/i against St Helens. Manfredi's push on Murphy was no different than Atkins' hand on Makinson (the first time Makinson got pretty much the same touch on the ball that Murphy was able to get tonight). So funny.

Consistency is the key for the match officials. However, they are consistently inconsistent.

Still, on the plus side, we won't hear from the likes of Meast, Giant Daz or Jools on here about how they got to the Grand Final. God help us if they actually would have went on and won it.

"Ooooo chokey chokey chokey.......ooooooooooo chokey chokey chokey"

Huddersfield don't bother to turn up for the playoffs again ... Standard..!

a proper underwhelming semi final...........

hope the leeds v sts is much better.tonights game was utter dire..but well done to the thugs.

We have the "always your year" tag but surely Huddersfield are the perennial "bottlers".

dont think we're in a position to preach as far as play offs / grand finals go. Disappointed for hudds, yes they had a couple of numpties come on here, but they are are good bunch, and I wanted them to get to Old Trafford, even if I thought it unlikely.

A word on john Bateman, God the guy is a horrible swine, but I wish he was wearing P&B. Lots of quality and lots of niggle, I know we were very interested in him at one point but backed off after having an offer turned down. Him Currie and hughes would have made a great wire back row.

Worst Play-off Semi-final/Grand Final Eliminator, ever.

I felt for Huddersfield. Just couldn't get to the pace of the game. Wigan just got on the ground quicker and played the ball lightening quick and slowed gown the Huddersfield attack.

The poor kid on the left centre didn't turn up either, think they got it wrong, should have kept Ta'ai at loose and Ferres at second row, give Wardle a go a Bateman. Connor had chances just couldn't do anything with them

terrible game... turned it off at half time.

I fell asleep during 2nd half ,I gave up struggling to keep eyes open in face of such a rubbish game , if I was Danny Brough I'd look for another club Leeds ??

Wigan were very aggressive as normal and Hudds just didn't respond to it. Handling errors, poor pass choices and surprisingly for them, high missed tackle count. Wigan were good but the Giants couldn't have played any worse. Tonights game should be a cracker though.

The mass of empty seats visible during the broadcast was a very poor advertisement for our sport, it was a semi for godssake!

Spot on Wigan didn't have to be good just efficient, I wanted Huddersfield to win but they were just plain average, well done to Wigan.

I'd rather he won no trophies with someone else tbh.

I'd prefer he stayed with Huddersfield unless he came here , I was saying if I was Brough I'd be looking to win something in my career

None of the big clubs have ever been interested in signing danny brough for the simple reason that he is massively overrated. Classic big fish, small pond player. Probably the only thing mcnamara has ever got right was saying he wasn't good enough to play for England.

Never produces in the really big games.

Hudds couldn't play any worse, of course they could.
They did last year in the same fixture when they lost 57-4.