Come on lets put it to a vote on whether Eddie & Stevo should quit, worst commentators in superleague.

No point Stevo retirement end of season.

I thought this was his penultimate season?

Haven't they changed ? It's been some time since I muted the commentary so can't judge.

Nowt wrong with them.

RL fans in hissy fit, when commentators aren't praising their team to the skies, shocker

Why? I quite enjoyed them today.

Eddie was just on TalkSport having a chat with former England RU hooker Brian Moore, and it was very interesting. Away from the Sky cameras, he comes across as very knowledgable. People just pick up on traits that he has and if they are not to their satisfaction, he's hated. Same with Stevo.

Crux of the matter is they are doing a job that everyone wants to do, or think that they can do better, when they really can't.

There are not many of us as knowledgeable as Stevo. Although many of us wish to think so.

He's played the game at his highest level in the NRL and was one of the first big British successes over there.

What about John Wells?

Does he not know what he is talking about?

At this moment in time it looks increasingly like you certainly don't.

You cant have it both ways.

if you want to big up the knowledge of a pundit, that's fine... But you cant then say that you dont 'give 2 monkeys' when another one doesn't agree with your biased opinion.

Not bias.
It's there for all to see unless they choose not too.

But I don't see how Jon Wells has better authority on the decision to play Bridge at 6 than Tony Smith.

Now back on topic....swap Stevo for jon Wells?

I give up.. I just don't think you understand words properly.

Its the only possible explanation for how you conjure up absolute drivel like
'But I don't see how Jon Wells has better authority on the decision to play Bridge at 6 than Tony Smith'

All because Wells quite rightly pointed out that Bridge doesn't look comfortable at 6, as its not his usual position... Bridge is filling in at 6 and he is doing ok.. But you seem to see him as the worlds greatest stand off. When someone suggests other wise you throw your arms in the air then type cryptic nonsense.

No bias though.

I just wish they would commentate on the actual game instead of trying to ref it from beginning to end.. I do think they need to get shut of Stuart Cummings out of the commentary box, and if they just commentate on the action I'm ok with Stevo and Eddie.

You opinion is greatly excepted and debate is good.
No bias though.
If Bridge had of played pants I'd be the first to be saying we need another halfback or we need another quality prop....I have previous in that department and been slated over and over.
At this time we don't need a halfback.
Bridge is not the make do or back up 6 in this team now because GOB is fit. So he is in there on merit. I haven't seen anything in this early season performances to suggest Myler will remove him either.
So let's agree to disagree. I except your view he is a stop gap.
Back on topic. I like Stevo.

Agreed with that.

Asotasi was the the catalyst to their fight back.....just saying.


Keeping that comment in here as it is by and large, irrelevant

Indeed. I have no problem with Eddie & Stevo, very passionate and knowledgeable. Some of the complaining about them is hilarious, not to mention ridiculous

They're fine and if you want to contrast knowledge of and ability to play the game versus ability to describe what you are seeing in such a manner see Jiffy Davies.

Lovely fella, absolute genius on the pitch, but as far as commentary goes he's as dull as a stag do in Workington.

"its very simpull troy Ray...."

Stevo and Cummings were obsessed with finding fault and foul play in everything we did on Sunday. Eddie did his 'it is Saints, after all' pitch as they started to make a comeback and my fist almost went through the screen.

They are rubbish commentators, listen to a few others such as Ray French getting on a bit now but he knows who the players are, Eddie and Stevo spend most the time slagging the official anything but stating who has got the ball, who is tackling him, before I go any further on this matter listen to a few of the NRL commentary's, really are top notch, Eddie and Stevo must drive quite a few possible new supporters away from our sport with their constant drivel.

totally agree...im sure it was bridge who took a tap and his boot hardly made contact with the ball..rightly they were quick to make comment along with cummings..but when sts kicked off nearly all there players were in front of the kicker,youve guessed it nowt said..there are more but id be on here all night typing it out

I absolutely love them and have so much respect for the pair. They definitely made it much easier for me to get into the sport and people will miss them when they are gone.

I think some people need to T R Y to lighten up a little.

The pair of them really come across as clowns & i don't think Stevo would be out of place commenting on the hideous sport of American wrestling. I suppose they are trying in their own way to inject some humour in the commentary. We should at least be thankful that we haven't got to listen to the sleep inducing British football commentatorzzzzzz.