3 minutes into tonights game he had to mention wigan do something better than anyone else,im sure im watching HKR V Catalan?

Nothing new to report then

It's Friday

It's Five to Five

It's time for....





a Phil Clarke thread

Knock ons all over the place because of the weather but what about that for a finish? Great viewing.

I have only once agreed with phil and that was over the greenshields try late on

You mean the try that wasn't? What's the point of having a Video Ref when it's Ian Smith?

i was calling no try for that then phil clarke made a lot of sense (shudder) all angles have to prove that it isn't a try and one angle wasnt conclusive so benifit of the doubt goes to the attacker

2 angles show no try then the side on angle shows he had downward pressure so i think that one angle was conclusive and also benefit of the doubt would have been sufficent

into the ring, did it?" I'm sick of him!

Surely if two angles show that there was daylight between hand and ball, then there was daylight! Also, all angles didn't prove that Hornes attempt was 'no try' so where was benefit of doubt there?