Who will be up in front of panel on tuesday,pretty sure some one will be,im expecting Benny prob be one?

what for..showing his dis-pleasure at being man handled by the spoilt one...no case to answer

Agree with that,but dont see them monkey's at red hall seeing it that way.

Can't think of anything to be honest.

Tomkins for spitting his dummy out!

Lima for throwing out at Woody at the PTB??

I'd be surprised if Benny gets off scott free if I'm honest. No matter what instigated it, the RFL have previous on punishing the retaliator (Remember Radford on Bailey).

Can you be punished for hitting your own player ?
Westwood swung but actually hit Solomona on the back of the shoulder ! Tompkins on the other hand is a scrote and should get 20 matches for being a cheatin little weasel watch him closely he is actually dirtier than his scumbag brother he just runs off quicker 1 the attack on Cunninghams knee in last seasons game at stains which hegot away with will live in my memory as one of the biggest injustices in RL history .
he has buckets of talent but spoils it with his dirty antics

I haven't seen a good quality replay of the incident yet so I can't comment on whether Westwood made clean contact or not, but don't forget the RL rules also take in to account "intent". It's perfectly justifiable in the rules for throwing a punch if there was intent to harm, whether it connected or not.

I'd agree about Tomkins - probably one of the most talented young players (if not the most talented) around right now, but the niggles and particularly the trapping the tacklers arm thing, spoil it and makes my blood boil.

I'm pretty sure I noticed Clarke try something similar against Hull KR unfortunately, very much in line with where we stand in the south and was very disappointed to see it

Oh woe is me. Players have been doing this in RL since about 1910.

The difference between the odd cheeky one and Tomkins is that Tomkins does it every time he gets tackled.

Yep, players do try to con the ref on occasion. And the problem people (including me) have with Tomkins is not so much that he does it, but the frequency of which he does it.

What does baffle me is that sometimes he appears to do it while a touch judge is looking directly at it, with a perfect line of sight, yet decides not to inform the referee what he's up to. I do remember a challenge cup tie against Leeds at Headingly one year where Senior conceeded a penalty when trying to win one for his team by flapping about and making it appear that he was being held down, so clearly the refs are capable of penalising the correct person, they just tend not to.

All the stick you give to sam is great ..... It has "we wish he played for us" ..written all over it.

Mick Higham might be up this week, possibly putting undue pressure on the shoulder joint in a chicken wing type tackle

Don't deny it but I bet playing for us he would be a better player who channels his anger and frustration into positive aspects of his game. Are are you Wiganers still saying Maguire is a better coach than Smith?

Mcilorum for twisting Solomona`s knees just before half time.

Comfortably so, yes.

Haha

oh thanks. I'm having a hectic day. Some things always bring a smile to my face. Moronic pies. It's like watching Jeremy Kyle, except more brain dead.

He's earnt a week off.

Isn't this after-game disciplnary reporting thing all a little un-Rugby League like?

By all means pick out anything that is truly against the spirit of the game, but a bit of a punch up??....



Seems to me its getting like schooldays stuff, snitching on people, because you simply hold a bit of a grudge....Personally, I find it a bit distasteful and I think a simple spur-of-the-moment fracas like Westwood's and Tomkins' should just be simply left alone.

Keep dreaming fella.

That Hodgson fella is doing alright for us at the minute.

Love your new avatar

If only there had been a clothes hook around, Big Dave could have lifted him onto it and left the gobe dangling !!!!

I'd like to see Solomona in the dock this week.

Charge : Bullying.

Fixed it for you son !!