Here are the sequence of images of Richie Mylers disallowed 'Try' at Huddersfield on Sunday.
I have left the images as they came out of the Camera with the officials blocking our view so you can see how close the official was when Richie went over.

I have put them in sequence and you can see Brett Hodgson coming in the at the last millisecond to dislodged the ball or not?

So is it a try or not?

Inconclusive your honour

Can't tell if he had control and got the ball down before it came out.

No try, he moves the arm not the ball.

No try, great defence by Hodgson. Great pictures too.

Inconclusive but stills (even as good as yours - fantastic as ever) will always be inconclusive. Even if you had a shot of the ball on the ground with a players hand on top of the ball you still couldn't say whether the ball had been dropped or not before the instant captured by the camera.

Apparently these things even themselves out over the course of the season. We are now 'owed' a few 50/50s (Richie v Hudds, Solo v wigan, Roberts 2nd v wigan) so hopefully we will be paid back when it really matters.

Penalty try 2 men in the tackle, as said prev hopefully even itself out over the course of the season. we must have a few in the bank now.

Cant be a penalty try, would just eb a penalty. Good defence.

If that try given for KR at the weekend was a try ,Mylers is defo a try imo !

Still think it should have been given. IGJ seemed to think it was ok and he was 3 feet away.

www.warringtonguardian.co.uk/wol ... disbelief/

www.warringtonguardian.co.uk/wol ... disbelief/

Inconclusive but try for mine...

no try.

great camera work tho, nice pics them.

its just unfortunate the frame is missing that would have shown where his hand was when the ball first made contact with the floor.

No try.

very inconclusive because it was a try

No try. It said so in the paper.

None of them were 50/50

.

Your coach disagrees with you

another full house at the galpharm i see

He has to say that



Watch the footage, clearly a knock on.

If we had a 24,500 seater stadium there would be lots of empty seats as well.

Not saying Huddersfield shouldn't be looking at improving their crowds, but they're far from the worst offenders.

Why does he have to say it? (I am assuming here we are talking about the Solomona no-try). He could easily have said that he 'thought the video referee got it right' and that would have been that. For what it's worth, I didn't think it was a try, or even anywhere near a 50/50 either, however in the light of some video referee decisions since I think we can count ourselves very unlucky!

Hence the wink, I don't agree with him.

They were not 50/50, they were pretty damn clear cut IMO.