Worst case all the above are out

Harrison----Monaghan----Cooper
-----Anderson-----King---------
-------------Grix---------------

Clarke
Mitchell
Higham
Tyke

if that's the pack v Hudderfield..we are in deep e

The Carvell high tackle looked bad in the ground, swinging arm right on the chin, anybody watched it back on TV, was it that bad?

it was a lazy challenge...no intent WHATSOEVER.

I was surprised it went on report...because Ganson had a clear sight of what happened...I don't know why he didn't deal with it there and then if it was so bad!

I think Brett took a high shot as well...it happens...without intent.

Personally wish he'd sent him off, we'd have coped and the RFL would have deemed that punishment enough

This is exactly what i was thinking, game was over at that point, if he is banned, I think we could really stuggle against Hudds pack.



Suppose the importance of that "tackle" may hinge on the fitness of Wood, Morley and co.

Sky sport website is reporting no Moz next week

My mates a journo and spoke to Smith earlier in the week and he was pretty hopeful on Morley being fit for the first play off game. He said the op had gone very well.

Not watched it yet - ban for Carvell?

intent is irrelevant, players have been picking up bans for lazy/clumsy high tackles for quite some time now and I don't see any reason why Carvell won't get a minimum 1 match ban for it. If he doesn't, then he'll be extremely fortunate.

why didn't Ganson do anything about it on the pitch then?..he had clear line of sight...if the challenge was so bad surely he should have been sent off.

Don't ask me mate, I'm only basing my expectations of a ban on the precedent set by the disciplinary for the past couple of years. If he's not called to the disciplinary, I'll be relieved. If he is called to it, I won't be surprised.

Hopefully Sol passes the head test and Woody is back,
the rest i think will definitely miss the next game.

Did Solomona injure his leg as well?.....he seemed to be limping off the pitch.

Quote from Tony Smith after tonights game

"We've got a bit of a rematch with Huddersfield, and we would like to think we will manage the game a lot better than we did last year," said Smith, who also confirmed captain Adrian Morley is unlikely to face the Giants owing to the eye surgery he had earlier this week."

Makes sense to take it easy with that one as even though the game is a big one there's more important battles to come.

I've just watched the match back, Carvell's tackle looked a little late and very lazy. I wouldn't be surprised if he just received a caution, after all he threw his hands up and fully acknowledged his wrong doing.

Very difficult to predict the disciplinary panel. Could be a fine, could be a 1 match ban.

To be fair to Carvell, he acknowledged it was a high shot but with no malice in it.

Carvell won't be banned for that and surely Woody and Moz will be back. Biggest doubt will be Solomona. Is there any chance that Westwood might be able to play again this season?

The match agianst Hudds will be difficult. We always struggle against them because (I reckon) they've the biggest pack in SL.

We will definately need Moz back (as long as there's no danger to his health). I spoke to him last night and he said he thought he'd be back next week.

Solo was not in a good state - even at 10.30pm when they came out to get on the bus. It was 'only' concussion. No mention of the leg - just wouldn't do what they were told becasue of the bang to the head....

Don't like the idea of Woody rushing back using injections - so I rate him 50/50.
Carvell .... looked bad at the match unfortunately, not seen Sky - I think a 1 match ban is quite likely.
Bridge said he'd just got a knock to the knee area, but it really didn't look too good. It was too early to say if there was any serious damage.
Monas was suffering a lot of bumps and bruises, but should be OK.

With Moz playing we'll be OK.
Without him, we have a massive problem.

Props - Cooper, Moz
Hooker - Monas
2nd row - Anderson, King
LF - Grix

Briers, Myler (both OK injury wise)

Back - Hodgeson, Riley, Atkins, Blythe, Joel
Bench - Mitchell, McCarthy, Harrison and 1 from Clarke or Higham

That's a really 'light' bench if no Moz - and even with him we'll have a real fight on our hands.

If he goes in a Wigan shirt he will get off.

1 match most likely......Not malicious, but still a pretty rotten tackle, technique wise.....His remorse was probably an acknowledgement of how poor a tackle it was.

is chris hill available to play ?

If Carvell gets a ban, I'll be surprised if Morley doesn't make himself available.

Pessimistic bunch aren't we