If you'd have asked at half time I would have said Atkins, but as it stands I find it difficult to argue with that.

Boring. Why can't you just accept another fans' view rather than trying to turn it into a stupid inter-club bitchfest?

The knock-on/ball steal decision changed the game.

Watch the Cas players LEFT hand pushing down on the ball, not his right hand grabbing at the arm. No problem with that call.

The ball steal was the correct decision. Yes, Shentons right hand pulled the arm away, but his left clearly pushes the ball down - it's partially hidden by the Warrington player behind, but definitely the right call.

It's the second time in two weeks the sky "commentators" have watched the wrong hand reffing it (same happened vs Saints)

I can accept another fans view but not when its someone bitchin about ref decisions when your club as been on end of some dubious stuff aswell,as of all clubs at some point.

Stef was brilliant again, Atkins had a great game and J Monas is class

Shenton's hands were on the ball but I don't think he pushed it out. You could tell by Chris Bridge's reaction he'd just dropped it.

I don't listen to Sky commentary as it's awful.

Should be a good game on Friday anyway. Hope plenty of Wolfs come to the DW.

My money is on us going to Wigan.

Were you actually watching the game at any point at all?

100%.

Should be a classic.

Given our record V Saints at Langtree, no chance they will pick us.

Lol no i was watchin coronation street repeats. REALLY no way can you say in parts of that gamedid we look like we wanted it, and we got very lucky with some decisions.

Don't put your hands on the ball, dont risk the penalty

I think it was the right call though ...

Is anyone due back for Warrington? Mcmanus does like to cut his nose off to spite his face when it comes to his morals ...

Whatever happens we'll play Wigan at some point. If Saints pick us, we'll beat them, but I can see them picking the winners of tomorrows game. We'll go to Wigan and whoever takes that game will win the GF.

I actually thought it was a very clinical defensive display from Wire. The speed at the play of ball and around the rook was as quick as we have ever played all season.

Individual errors kept Cas in it. Wood being the the biggest villain.

Wouldn't be surprised if we did pick Warrington. Given what McManus has said in the past, we will ALWAYS pick the lowest ranked. Always have so far.

If Huddersfield beat Catalans, you could well have a bye to the final. Would be better for the sport too IMO. I think you'll win it this year so if the final isn't you and Wigan it will be a whitewash. If Saints end up at OT against either Wire or Wigan and it'd be over after 20 minutes.

dont worry he`ll have his wigan home top on next week and if it does get a bit nippy i love thug mcchloride vest under neath

how ironic a wiganer having the barefaced cheek to question a decision that went in our favour when they get numerous over a season...you could`nt make it up..

Thought Asotasi had his best game and made some excellent drives. Stef was top draw though and clear mom. It looks like wigan and let's hope everyone can get a good rest and hope we have super Ben back.

Already had this with him.guess they just worried about us rather than taking on cas.

100% agree with this,no disrespect to other teams left but i really can not see past us or Wigan wiinning the GF.

McManus was very vocal about club call in year one and said that he would only ever chose the lowest rank team.
By choosing Hudds over the Wire is hypocritical or he has yet to tell us he has now bought into the concept?

He will pick Wire for sure.

Really hope he does.

I'm going to make myself unpopular here - I thought we rode our luck tonight, got the kind of 50/50 calls that are reserved for Wigan & Leeds and gave a very laboured Cas team a hint of a comeback.

The first 20 minutes we were totally in control and looked like we relaxed alarmingly. The error rate escalated alarmingly, with Wood looking a total liability, and we started to get ragged. At 10-12 I was genuinely worried but a piece of sheer class by Ratchford saw us home.

I know we are patched up, beat up and out on our collective feet, and yet at times tonight we were fantastic, but I think we'll probably bow out with dignity next week irrespective of who we play. That will be no disgrace, it's been a season of development, discovery and genuine progress.

I must have seen a different game. Never thought we would lose.