Noble could have done that job the players turned your team around not smith

And to say he's done a better job than madge is stupid

could you re-type that so that it makes sense please.

*edit..after reading it again i think you're possibly the most stupid person in this thread.

Please stop, you're embarrassing yourself, now

Not really a fact is it.

the players turned our team around.... not smith

Oh yeah, I guess that bad start to the season under Lowes, then going on to win the challenge cup under Smith was just my imagination

Of course

Roberts
Gleeson
Carmont
Richards
Deacon
leuluai
Fielden
Coley
Finch
Hoffman
Lima

You are right - for a moment I thought you were mad

Ok smith coached england did sweet fa

He takes over a side signing near half a new squad what have done nothing with the players they had yet they win 2 cups that was not down to the coaching it was down to the squad getting alot stronger

Madge takes over a inconsistent team and makes them the most consistent in sl with 1 new signing

Madge is head and shoulders above any coach in sl

THIS is why brothers and sisters shouldn't sleep together.

Well then, dunno what the RFL are waiting for, England would clearly win the world cup under Madge.

We had 5 overseas players in our squad last week

Do you not think he would make a big diffrence?

Look at millward with you men won everything but yet couldn't coach a bunch of kids now cause he aint got that squad he had

Funny coming from a wire

That wasn't really your point. Just because they're not from overseas, doesn't mean that you 'brought them through the ranks'.

Not with England, no. I think they're a lost cause.

He doesn't seem to understand 'words'.

Sorry forgot smith is a better coach than madge

have you changed that grubby grey jumper yet?

You colour blind?

your apology is duly noted.

Tony Smith is a very good coach but no way could he have done what Madge did with Wigan during that first season.

On 'homegrown players' We have 12 in our 19 man squad Wire have 6 in theirs. Although over recent years Wire have improved massively in the development of their younger players IMO.

Can't wait for the game tonight, should be very tight, can't call it!

We had one the previous week. Madge made you a more consistent team, you had made the previous three grand final eliminators, he just took you the next step. Tony Smith took over a very underachieving Leeds team and turned them into double grand final winners with a team containing many players who came through the Leeds youth set-up. Tony Smith took over a team of underachievers at Wire. As far as I can remember Tony Smith has signed Mathers, Solomona, Atkins, Myler, Hodgson and Joel Monaghan. In the same time frame Wigan have brought in Gleeson, Deacon, Lima, Hoffman, Finch. Not much difference their to be honest.

Mathers
Smith
Walker
Calderwood
Maguire
Burrow
Sinfield
Hall
Diskin
JJB
Kirke
Ablett


Should I go on? It's clear that Tony Smith hasn't got a clue.

That's the point though, Tony Smith took a team from ninth or wherever it was to 3rd and to repeat as challenge cup winners. Madge took you from grand final eliminator to grand final winners. Not that big a step. Both are great coaches and both set's of fans are happy with what they have at the minute. Let's leave it there.

so its a grubby white top?

that is grubby then.

So you could argue a strong case that Warrington have seen a greater improvement under Smith than Wigan have under 'madge'.