But he is the fall-guy. Any mistake he makes,the fans are on his back straight away,Adamson knocked on on the second play last night,nothing said,imagine the abuse Smith would have received if he had knocked-on.
FWIW I think Smith has been disappointing,but he's not as bad as people try to make out.Part of this is I suppose because fans see him keeping Ratchford from the stand-off position,but that is McRae's decision,whether you agree with it or not.
If you were serious with your "ratings",then to give Smith 1/10 on last night's game suggests you ARE treating him as this seasons scapegoat.

are you his hairdresser?

Unlike your £250K a season centre who must be the worst value for money player ever to play in SL.



And as for being better this season he couldn't possibly be any worse than last year!

Total myth, he was okay last season as well, and he isn't on nowhere near 250k a season, more like half.

So he's lived up to your expectations then and been great value for money?

Caught by a veteran hooker