wonderful talent and i have to say may turn out to be better at full back than in the halves but a very dirty and niggly player. Check out him deliberately stamping on davi Fa alogos hand at 15 minutes and 37 seconds of yesterdays game. just before he gives a penalty away

There are plenty of examples in the history of our game to show that being a great talent or dirty player are not mutually exclusive!

Not like a Hudds player would ever deliberately stamp

i would say a bit of both great player at times but also very niggly and sneaky at other times, certainly not yet the world beater sky and wigan would have us believe.

Why didn't Fa'alogo punch him in the face? He's punched his own coach in the face before, but leaves an opposition player alone?

Good to see the point of the thread completely bypassing so many people...

He is a world beater in my eyes. I’m sorry but people think you can only be world beaters if you’ve either had a long and respectable career with Great Britain or played down under.

Some people would probably rate Mark Flanagan higher than Sam Tomkins just for the fact Mark plays in Australia. I enjoy watching Sam play and that’s that!

he didn't stamp on him.

Give it up. Everyone saw Mason for the cheap shot dirty little thug he is, and Tomkins for the wonderful talent he is.

If you bother watch the slow-mo just before he's carded, Mason stands on Fielden's right foot before stamping on his left ankle. Brave man. Very big. Couldn't manage to smash Stu in the tackle so he goes for an unsighted dig. Fielden doesn't see who does it, which is why he has a go at the markers. Nice to see Mason go hiding when the fists start flying.

BTW, 15 mins 37 seconds is the fight. The alleged Tomkins 'stamp' is at 16 mins 37. If you can call it a stamp; he's in the act of tackling, Faalogo has his hand on the floor and the front Tomkin's boot touches it. Faalogo doesn't even react. Pointing at that and wailing "but Sam did it as well!!!" (he didn't) doesn't distract from Mason being a major league cheapshot pussy.

BTW, how many Giants fans were evicted last night?? I saw at least 2 being removed and heard of a few more.

Can't he be both?

Unfortunately i was not there last night but on my previous visits to the DW there is always a bit of tension with the fans as they continue to put Huddersfield in with the Home fans. Even though we had 500 to 600 there they did not open the away stand. In a game as full of controversy as yesterdays it is not surprising there were a few incidents. Those fans who were there may be able to best comment on the indavidual details.

maybe the Huddersfield fans responded to being called Yorkshire b'stards which is the ephithet they usually throw at us.

You're right, you weren't there!

In regards to Tomkins, he has no talent and he's a dirty player.

Which is strange, because he is one of Super League's top players, an England first team regular and a fans favourite at Wigan.

We wouldn't have him any other way. Get over him.

Tomkins is one of those players other teams hate because he's good, as opposed to Mason who they hate cause he's a crap imitation of a school bully.

Stored for the next time you have a pop at the likes of Ryan Bailey...

Yes the Wife said i had to choose Wigan away or Catalans away.
I had to accept i would end up going to perpignan instead What a blow






You comments about Tomkins are interesting though. Dirty , niggly player but he is our player so we love him. Difference is Huddersfield fans did not have to have 10 pages going on at him like you lot did at Mason. ( except when boredom crept in and a spot of fishing seemed in order).

Can't beat a good overeaction


The two who were led away by us were given a talking to in the concourse then went back to their seats.

Tomkins is a fantastic player. I wish he played for warrington.

I saw them being taken away, then a little later the bloke in front of us took his kid to the toilet, came back and said there were a few more being shown the door. Fair enough, but they were certainly a little over-excited and I saw several Wigan fans move away from them, mainly those with kids.

Still, the fat lad who was on the verge of tears after Sam's try gave us all a good laugh.

Not as much as a laugh as the Gooners leaving with 5 minutes to go and only 2 points in it...

That's probably because there aren't enough Huddersfield supporters to generate 10 pages of posts on your forum, and the fact there's only you and a couple of other Huddersfield supporters who think Sam actually did wrong.

He's a real chav is young Sam. His army issue hair cut doesn't do anything for him. It makes him look like an extra from Prison Break, probably one of T-Bag's 'friends'.

Fantastic player. But I don't think the sly behaviour at times does him any good. It's going to get him into trouble and isn't a worthwhile part of his game. He could be aggressive without being stupid, quality players don't descend to those levels.

Great player.

Always gives 100% and is a winner, that'll do me in an England shirt.

I was going to say that, and im a hudds fan :/

Have you seen Briers lately?