Whilst he ran in it supremely well, you can't help but be mystified by the video ref ignoring the 2 or 3 knock ons he did onto Roby. We are ignoring technicalities like multiple knock ons in order to reward good play?

Bizarre.

You didn't listen to Eddie & Stevo. It was cos it looked good they gave the try.....

A joke, although it was great to see Carvell go.

Proves once and for all that some of the officials simply don't know or understand the rules.

Pathetic.

I hate technicalities anyway. A knock on should only apply if it hits the floor.

Beyonce [ishould[/i be coming to my house tonight for a massage, but it's not the way things are.

with out the vid ref it would of been given straight away, not saying that is the right thing but it just would

I don't think it would, because he enquired over that incident, meaning he saw it well enough to make a judgement on. It was clearly a knock on, it bounced between the two like a pinball in real time.

But you'd throw out life's rule book if she did wouldn't you?

I'd refer it upstairs to the video wife.

Except when a Halifax player does it in the Semi-Final of the NRC

He didn't knock on. He threw it away

Gleeson didn't throw it away. He knocked on, ran over the ball and then ran back and picked it up. Then you scored a try. We didn't hear such a tough stance from you then, did we?

Referee didn't think so and he sees everything. I didn't see it. I only see things that i want to. Things like this don't register with my brain. Mind you, the dirty thuggy cowardly things that Toa-Kohe Love gets away with kinda evens these injustices out.

Pathetic decision. Not the first time it's happened this year aswell.

Ganson is a ****.

At least you can't say that Ganson is biased for Saints.

There was also an earlier incident, pass goes to Wilken who can,t catch it goes backwards over his shoulder, knock on scrum to Warrington.

High tackle bursts Grix mouth open.

Play on.............................

Thats what I thought, they were almost saying the knock on should be ignored because it was a great run!

Yea that was a bizarre one.

this is the same set of numpties that have advocated some tries being worth moe than other depending on how good they look though.

It looked nothing on Sky. The contact with the mouth was so quick you couldn't see it clearly even on slo-mo. No doubt that he did make contact but it was hardly a classic hit shot, more of a flailaing arm.

We were watching a different game then...

If Ganson says that ball didnt touch Roby before Carvell regathered then he shouldnt video ref anymore. If another offence occured resulting in a play on after it hit Roby then fair enough!

(Take nowt from Carvell though, he played to the whistle and ran it in for the try of his life. )

Maybe eddie was right the RFL now do video ref decisions based on morality not fact

I was a retarded decision, i dont know how ganson could not see the ball being knowed on into roby two if not three times

Althouigh it was ganson so maybe he does not know the rules after all