Point proven. Three loose forwards in that list (although one has spent an awful lot of time at six and he wasn't Sculthorpe or Farrell).

Good side, I dont understamd Carney though, he was a good finisher but defensively awful for us.

Radlinski
Albert
Lyon
Senior
Dallas
Harris
Long
Peacock
Cunningham
Fielden
Morley
Sculthorpe
Farrell

Wellens
Albert
Lyon
Senior
Vainikolo
Paul
Long
Graham
Cunningham
Fielden
Peacock
Farrell
Sculthorpe

A lot of quality players left out who did cross my mind, but these would just edge it for me

Tomkins
Robinson
Lyon
Senior
Vainikolo
Sculthorpe
Long
Graham
Cunningham
Peacock
Burgess S
Farrell A
Sinfield

I always liked Carney and thought he was a cracking winger. Maybe it's because he kept bloody scoring against us! Was it 2003 when he killed us off in the playoffs at Headingley?

01 Tomkins
02 Monaghan
03 Gidley
04 Lyon
05 Vainikolo
06 Harris
07 Barrett
08 Peacock
09 Lowes
10 Morley
11 Farrell
12 Sculthorpe
13 O'Loughlin

That's one of the requirements for the job of the England/GB coach isn't it?

Sculthorpe won 2 MOS awards playing 6.

Keith Senior at centre? Maybe in the forwards, he would have bn put in the back row if he had gone to the NRL. Some are even saying that Jack Reed should be put in there as his hands aren't good enough for centre.

Interesting that although The SL era has been heavily populated by Antipodean players, only Lyon, Vainakolo and maybe R.Paul would command a place in most people's team.

Scott Donald,Marcus Bai and Ryan Hall would disagree.

1. Sam Tomkins
2. Jason Robinson
3. Jamie Lyon
4. Paul Newlove
5. Lesley Vainakolo
6. Trent Barrett
7. Sean Long
8. James Graham
9. Kieron Cunningham
10. Stuart Fieldon
11. Jamie Peacock
12. Andy Farrell
13. Paul Sculthorpe

Is Sam Burgess eligible for this? He didn't play that much over here. So is A Johns eligible? Obviously not.

I'd imagine Burgess has played roughly as many if not more first grade games in the UK than he has in Oz

Wellens at FB....

Not even the best full back at Saints during the SL era.

He spent a few years at 6 as well as second row and loose forward.

Lowes better than Cunningham, priceless.

Yes, he has played in more matches for Bradford, but how many minutes has he played, was he on the bench a lot at the beginning of his career?

The idea that Keith Senior is one of the best two centres of Super League is a complete joke. He was not as good as Gidley. But most important, he was not as good as Steve Renouf.

The best Super League team is:

[iSam Tomkins (Wigan)

Jason Robinson (Wigan) Steve Renouf (Wigan), Jamie Lyon (St. Helens), Martin Offiah (London)

Trent Barrett (Wigan)
Andrew Johns (Warrington)

Paul Sculthorpe (St Helens)
Sam Burgess (Bradford) Jamie Peacock (Bradford)
James Graham (St Helens), Keiron Cunningham (St Helens), Adrian Morley (Leeds)
[/i

Your Vainikolo, Carney, Briers, Newlove, Gidley and Senior belong in the second and third best teams.

Whilst I agree wello, as good of a guy as he is, is probably somewhere position 5-10 in the list of superleague fullbacks, (I think I'd put him 4th but that may just be redvee sentiment :p) to say he isn't the best fullback in saints superleague history is a bold claim! Who do you think is better??? Don't let the sands of time dull his memory, he was top class in his day (and him not being able to maintain it, for more than a couple of seasons is probably the one reason he doesn't make it) model of consistency though.

My 13 (trying to take off the redvee specs)
1. Radlinski
2. Hall
3. Lyon
4. Senior
5. Vaikona
6. Sculthorpe (as was said 2 mos playing mainly stand off so it should be okay naming him here)
7. Lam
8. Anderson
9. Cunningham
10. Graham
11. Ellis (though he seems intent on working his way out of this list at hull...)
12. Peacock (was named in dream team 2 years on the run at second row so it should be fine)
13. Farrell

Paul Wellens
Ryan Hall
Leon Pryce
Michael Withers
Lesley Vainikolo
Danny McGuire
Paul Deacon
Stuart Fielden
Keiron Cunningham
Jamie Peacock
Paul Sculthorpe
Andy Farrell
Kevin Sinfield

James Graham
Chris Joynt
Rob Burrow
Paul Anderson

If I live to be 150 years old I still don't think I will understand why Joel Monaghan is so highly rated. Best of the Superleague era ffs?

Absolute nonsense. Renouf wasn't half as good as Newlove in Super League.

1. Stuart Spruce
2. Tevita Vaikona
3. Leon Pryce
4. Shontayne Hape
5. Lesley Vainikolo
6. Henry Paul
7. Robbie Paul
8. Joe Vagana
9. James Lowes
10. Stuart Fielden
11. Jamie Peacock
12. Bernard Dwyer
13. Brad McKay

14. Paul Deacon
15. Mike Forshaw
16. Brian McDermott
17. Paul Anderson

18. Sam Burgess

Not really...

I was just too cheerful a minute ago so I thought I'd depress myself.