Similar to NFL - Team able to challange one decision with the video ref. Maybe just for tries instantly ruled out by on field refs

Well at least we won't get robbed against Wakey by him next year lol

That's irrelevant when the video ref gets called in for EVERY try when he is there.

I haven’t read through all the four pages so apologies if this has been mentioned

Any kick from outside the 20m (that is the oppositions 20m) that goes dead in goal should be a scrum to the defending team or a tap if on the last tackle. Too many teams take the easy option of leathering the ball over the dead ball line on the last and set up for the 20m tap

If a team forms a scrum quickly to stop the clock, then they must contest that scrum with the players present.

If they want to change the make up of their pack (ie use all their forwards) the clock continues to run ....

I'd scrap the 40/20 rule on the last tackle. Sometimes this punishes an excellent defensive set as the team in posession has the opportunity to regain the ball, which would not have been possible with poorer defence.

I'd like to see the not breaking from the scrum untill the ball is out enforced, At times it is a joke with the receiver facing all the pack as soon as he gets the ball - physically impossible if they stay bound.

Some very good ideas.

But I still reckon my one tops the list....

When the ball is kicked dead in goal by the attacking team the current tap on the 20 restart is rubbish, the tap should be from where the kick was from.

This would encourage attacking teams to try kicks through when close to the line and stop 70 yard hoofs down field gaining 50 yards of territory.

IMO we've got enough rules already, a drive to simplify the game would improve it no end.

I would like to see the team who has just scored a try/penalty kick to the team who has just conceded.

Also, I think that if the ball goes forward despite whether the player regains control in mid air, it should be a knock on.

We tried that. Didn't seem to be a success.

Perhaps memories of Leeds putting 70+ points past us at Belle Vue, and every kick off followed by a try still haunts me today.

I would like to see the team who has just scored a try/penalty kick to the team who has just conceded
Tried that in the early 90s as a ploy to stop Wigan winning everything. Didn't work then wouldn't work this time.

That's a great suggestion. The current rule is a case of good play being penalised. Apart from that I would leave the laws as they are.

Wherever or whenever the Magic Weekend is, you either go or don't go - but you're not allowed to moan about it

But is it good play or just a bit of effort? After all if theyre good enough to charge it down and then gather in the ball they get possession.

im not sure why you would want this?

All that would do is punish the team who rushed to form the scrum and reward the team who wandered over and got their players in place.

Im not sure how the game would benefit?

How about tries from a kick don't get a conversion?

Players can't change nations once they have played for one nation, then wear their national flag over their name on their club shirt.

Touch judges with some Gonads

.....Which takes us back to Richard Keys and Andy Gray.

You have been watching RU again haven't you?

I've been saying this for years mate.

I'd rather talk to you than watch that yawnion.

I'd make Saints players actually touch the ball with their foot when they are playing the ball.

Ref's making a decision rather than putting something on report.

Fighting just 10 mins in the bin with no RFL fines after the fact.

Three good ideas, everyone loves a scrub up, no one likes someones head being taken off.

Is one of them mine?