My first instinct was no try, but on the replays I could see there was an argument for it to be given, would have been a tough call though.

he could of mistaken it for his willy

Super zoom is definitely needed to see that.

I said straight away it would be given, I just knew he was going to give it ......

Wigan were the better team BUT they only won because of some very dodgy decisions and are very very lucky.

If i was a HKR fan i would be gutted about losing that game on the basis of officials decisions and interpretations.

There's a surprising amount of people moaning about Charnleys second try (it wasn't a try) but no one mentioning what would have been his third (which clearly was a try, so evens up really). Funny that.

Also apparently there was no obstruction for KRs second try either.

I didn't think the other was a try, I didn't think he had any pressure on the ball and that the ball hit his hand after it hit the ground and bounced up.

We support Hull KR. We see it every week.

Charnley's in goal try should not have been given. Next one should have been given. Macalorum should have been sin binned for his spear tackle on the basis that Withers was sin binned for an apparent dangerous tackle (or was it the team warning still in effect from 10 sets and half time ago?)

I think people are moaning about a try been given when it was clearly put down on the in-goal line, without a doubt! The one given as a knock-on was 50/50 at best.

Pass back, hits wigan player on head we score a try not even looked at.
Forward pass given, never forward and wigsn score
The video refs disgraceful devision
Sending off etc etc
That was pretty much as bad as I've seen

It wasn't clearly a try. I'd have been happy for it to be given benefit of the doubt but it wasn't clear at all.


If that were given as obstruction Wigan would never score another try again.

It was a sin bin not sending off, though he should have been not only because of the team warning but also the dangerous tackle (I believe the words Cummins used were pulled the leg beyond normal movement) and then screaming at the ref like a petulant child.

So many tears in this thread. Great reading.

And Macallorums spear tackle wasn't dangerous enough for a sin bin?

You'll be beaten at wembley and found out in the playoffs.

Games like this where you get practically given wins give you false confidence.

you mean the one where he picks him up and lets go in the air? and the legs never go past the horizontal? it was never a speak tackle he was penalized for carrying on after the ref shouts held.

His name is McIlorum.

And it was O'Loughlin that made the tackle. At least get your own facts right before criticising the referees.

Bloody 'ell! I hope not. Go Wigan! LOL

Haha at least we'll compete in both.

Where will your club be in 3 Saturday's time, or around Sep/Oct?

To be fair, I'm not a Wigan supporter and don't give a stuff about your players. I just know that the officiating was a disgrace even just on that one point.

However, come the cup final, I'll be behind you 100%!

It's funny you would boast about being at wembley considering the draw you've had. Anyone in the top 8 would be at wembley with that draw.

You could say your appearence at wembley is down to circumstance.

Especially the semi final bye - another fix!

It's truly bemusing to see someone get a decision so wrong. I mean, how stupid do you have to be to award that try?

The forward pass that was given against Hull KR before the break was also a terrible call. That led to a wigan try nicely before HT, a 10 point swing.

Wigan were lucky to win. But I'm glad they did as it gives us a chance to go to 5th if we beat Catalan tomorrow

Isn't FlexWheeler a Leeds fan? If so he'll be at Headingley-West in early October.