How the hell was that try given??

Luckily it won't affect the outcome but come on?
Terrible decision.

Robert Hicks: "his hand misses the ball, it's a try"

Can't speyke

Unfortunately, ridiculous video referee decisions are becoming frequent.
Today's was bad, but I remember the one where Solomona was given a try when the ball clearly didn't touch the ground.
Until the stupid procedure of "proving the referee wrong" is scrapped we will continue to get decisions that are completely baffling.
Personally, I'd get rid of the VR altogether.

Unbelievable decision,how can any referee,having slow motion, give a try.

Campbell needs demoting for sending it up as a try in the first place, Hicks deserves to be sacked for "confirming" the call.

The idiots at Red Hall have managed to make themselves a laughing stock on national TV once again because they have woefully incompetent officials.

I blame Ben Thaler.

Well done Barry the Flag for calling that try.

Refs make one glaring error in a game well decided, Gronk calls for execution shocker

Didn't the ref signal no Try yet Hicks thought he has signalled Try for the last try of the game?

Last try - "if that's all we've got, it's a try".
The replay was totally conclusive you blind b@$tard.

So because it didn't matter mistakes are fine?



Officials need holding accountable for crap like that whether it decides a game or if it's 60-0, things like that should not happen.

But hey a Wakey troll singles me out again like all the time on this forum, obsessed

Good game of rugby though, yeah?

Got to say Cas were out played there. Think they did well defensively to contain Wigan. Quite an entertaining game now for a nil nil draw and penalties

He gave a try. Brian Noble was telling everyone he gave no try

Not really? That was an incredibly dull, low quality game.

Ah right, thanks.

Refs make mistakes all the time in every single game, get over it. FWIW had Cas been a bit more clinical in hand in the first half then who knows what would've happened in the second.

Silverwood IIRC didn't get dropped for that Solomona "try" in the Cas/Salford game.

Finally, I've only picked on your comments twice - ironically both on Wigan games. Not really obsessed, but embarrassed to see fans of any team whinge about the ref all the time.

So where on earth is the draw? They said it's red button but that's only showing some music festival thing.

It's on, you have to choose Challenge cup forum.

As bad as him sending Solomona's up as a try despite him clearly losing the ball. Thankfully the cameras caught him in touch anyway.

Wigan V Hull
Warrington V Wakefield

I can't see it either, just options to watch second-rate bands at Glastonbury.

Couldn't find the option anywhere on Freeview.

I got it but I'm on Virgin TV.

And Hicks did not once mention he had lost the ball!