Quote ="pmack17"Widdop 4 - Way out of his depth. Poor in defence, looked unfortortable under the high ball and showed nothing going forward
Goulding 5 - Again way out of his depth. An average club winger who has had a good season in a strong wigan team but shouldnt have been anyway near an international jersey
Shenton 7 - looked our best 3 quarter. Strong in defence + showed pace in attack
Atkins 4 - looked disinterested
Briscoe 6 - actually looked quite good. Deceptively strong going forward and in defence
Brown 4 - Way out of his depth. Poor in defence, woeful with ball in hand and kicking game was aweful
S Tomkins 7 - only dangerous player on the field for England
Fielden 5 - very average. Showed no aggression and made a poor error in the 1st half
Roby 6 - Not a starting hooker and is much better of the bench. Played ok is 1 of the few players that can play at this standard
Graham 5 - worked hard but not international standard. Not agressive in the tackle and lacks size at this level
Ellis 5 - hugely disappointing. Needed him to lead from the front went missing.
Burgess 4 - massive let down. Looked disinterested. No big hits. Poor work rate and again went missing when we needed him to lead from the front.
O'Loughlin 5 - again went missing. Not big enough or agressive at this level. thought he had his best season by a mile for wigan and his most average performance for england to date
Robinson 6 - tried hard but not up to this standard.
Griffin 4 - way out of his depth. How he got selected above Lynch, Coley and Scruton his baffling. Been average for Huddersfield all season and for such a big lump he plays well below his weight.
Westwood 6 - thought he looked 1 of our strongest forwards in the tackle but always gives penalties away because hes as thick as 2 planks + was pathetic in defence for the Shaun Kenny Dowall try
J Tomkins 5 - not enough game time to make any comment'"
O'loughlin went missing? yet made the most tackles out of anybody on the pitch and gave a couple of great passes. you need to watch the game mate, understand the J tomkins rating because of time on the pitch but he gavethe pass to shenton which sent him off. Goulding wasn't out of his depth, he made a heck of a lot of meters for a winger without making breaks. Robinson was also better than you suggest.
Roby had a poor first half but much better second and thought westwood was really good when he came on.
But still, i don't see what what O'loughlin has to do for peopel to rate him.
Oh wait i've only just noticed the rating you gave Graham, making your whole post no longer valid.
