Need I say no more.

That's ineligant

Fact is we need him back asap.

McNamara must be man enough to let the swearing spat between them both lay to rest.

not sure how he could have helped you yesterday considering he was injured

Would have probably still played better on one leg than Sheriffe or Sykes.

Are you sure he wants to come back?

I do like Halley.

He is certainly a better full back than Platt (but that isnt sayin much.)

However I do not think (as some others seem to) that he is the messiah and must be up in the team immediately.

He can not make much of a difference at either FB or on the wing.

Its creative players we are lacking and I do not see Halley as the creative spark that would put this team right.

We'll have him - especialy as Roger Meli is still missing

I agree with that. However he would be an improvement at fullback or wing (for Platt/Sykes or Sheriffe). Whenever we can have an improvement in the team, it certainly won't hurt. You are correct though in that to have a drastic improvement, we need someone with some creativity.

TBH I don't think Halley would improve us. Certainly not on the wings as we've not giving any ball out wide

Ideally i`d drop sykes for crookes- might as well blood him since seasons gone, and drop sherrife for halley, put platt back in at fb, when tupou fit put him on bench and when solo back put him on bench for kopczak.

Team platt, halley, nero, crookes, tadulala, jefferies, deacs, lynch, newton, burgess, menzies, cook, morrison, tupou, scruton, langley, solomona.

That's spot on.

We could have Vainikolo on the wing but it really wouldn't matter, our wingers just aren't getting enough ball atm.

deary me

Although the wings aren't getting enough service in attack, that's no excuse for the poor defensive work that's come from Sheriffe. Yesterday especially, he was asleep half the time, although admittedly he wasn't alone in that.

A few times I heard people shout at him for a lack of "oomph" and looking like his head was elsewhere, and I struggled to disagree.

No doubt Sheriffe's strength is his pace and he needs some decent service to show that, but his weaknesses are definitely being shown up already.

He didn't look that fast when he was trying to catch Yeaman.

TBF he looked pacier than Ian van Bellen.