Where's the fun in that?



I may start a poll where we get to choose between Alex Murphy, Andy Goodway, Barry Seabourne and Mike Bassett.

If this is true, who are the likely replacements?

The club has a history of promoting from within (Menzies?), but surely this is the time to bring in an experienced NRL taskmaster as seen in the recent success of Brown at Hudds and maybe also Maguire at Wigan?

I'd be worried if you get any of the 'usual suspects' that are touted by fans following these kinds of rumours:

Shaun McRae
Jon Sharp
Ellery Hanley
Ian Millward
Brian Noble
John Kear
Iestyn Harris
etc

Cullen definitely gets my vote

I don't see much truth in it tbh.


But i'd take Noble or Kear, but Aussies are the way to go with coaches, Taylor or Foulkes would be good aswell.

TBF he has been number 2 at our club during his time in charge so making it official seems sensible.

Beaver!

Lee St Hillaire.

Like Bit of Bully I wouldn't be surprised if Menzies ends up with it.

Wonder if Michael Hagan fancies a full time job again?

Does he even have his coaching badges?

Hmmm. I can't think of many players that have gone from player straight to first team coach and suceeded at a senior level. In fact I can't think of any.

Cue two page list of examples....

Brian McDermott would be another poor selection

Doesn't matter it will be Lee St Hillaire. Smith, Elliot, Noble, Macnamara, St Hillaire, ?

I can think of a few who've had a stab at it but not done very well and that's some time ago. Nowadays it's rarer than it used to be because generally you need to develop as a coach for a few years before getting a head coach job.

Gary Schofield?

Hope it's true

Same. We need someone like Folkes.

If the rumour turns out to be true, then I feel it is important we go with somebody experienced. By 2011 we could have a pretty useful squad if we can bring in a couple of quality players. Thankfully we have plenty of time to pick who we believe ticks all our boxes.

As for McNamara, if he has been offered the assistant job at Sydney then it would be a huge move for him. I think any coach could learn a great deal from working alongside Brian Smith. If somebody offered me a very good job in Aus, I think I'd find it pretty tough to turn down too!

I think you only have to look at what Brown has done to Hudds, McGuire at Wigan (especially with the previously underperforming Richards), Smith with WIre (ditto Matt King) to realise you should spend time there to better yourself.

Working in the NRL will be more of a benefit to him than working with Brian Smith IMO. In NRL terms he's a bit of a journeyman coach these days, and despite a long career down there with some very talented players at his disposal he has never won a premiership.

Anyway, hasn't McNamara already worked with Smith, both as a player and during a brief stint when he took over from Noble? I'd question the further benefits of him working with Smith as opposed to being an NRL assistant in general...

I'd say the next coach is pretty much nailed on to be someone who is currently an assistant NRL coach. Can't see the point, at all, of going with any of the names so far mentioned except possibly Menzies, but I don't know if he intends to go into coaching or has any badges. If he does, I can see him becoming the next Wayne Bennett. I wouldn't mind at all letting him experiment on us.

Well you're wrong it's going to be Lee St hillaire.

Stop saying that!

Wrong? What do you mean? If we did go with St Hilaire, I can't see the point. Just to check your claim, I asked myself whether I can in fact see the point, but the reply I got was no, I really can't see the point. Therefore I wasn't wrong, I deffo couldn't and can't see the point.

HTH