I read the article as basically saying heath is off and next year it's OBrien and diskin. But saying that earlier this year when the heath to Catalans rumors were going around he said on twitter he is a bull for another year . But I suppose that means nothing really.

The deal offered to him was 50% less than what he was on on the original 3yr deal he came on.

Its a very good contract club wise as it gets rid of one of our biggest earners but keeps the experience at the club. We cant let them both go. I would have preffered Le'Strange as he has been better than Diskin for the last 3 years

Im looking forward to the 2 or 3 quota spots we are going to have avalible. We just need to know what Purtell has decided now. I heard yesterday we are looking at a centre from Cronulla called Pomeroy. Dont know how true it is though.

The only reason I can see Diskin being retained is that the club know that Heath is leaving at the end of the year.

TBH I don't think Diskin is half as bad as some make out. He's had some unimpressive games this season but so has L'Estrange. The main priority should be keeping O'Brien happy as he's the future.

Aye,that would be the only reason I guess.But he's still a dead weight imo.

FC actually makes reference to Diskin being a good defender, which is worrying because Diskin is far from it. Hanbury's first try on Sunday being a prime example of his 'defending'.

Still, I can't blame Heath for wanting to go back home to raise his child. I wonder what the clause is in his contract exactly, could we be looking at another transfer fee? Not sure the aussies will pay too much because transfer fees actually count towards the salary cap over there.

Joe how long have you had access to what players are on or have been offered

It's depressing enough this morning with this news,without you adding to it

Please please don't say they can now sign a certain prop from South Sydney

Mole has him down as in talks with Cronulla.

Hope they have got permission from the bulls,seen as though he's contracted to us in Joes little world

Im getting the bad feeling the Leeds old boys are being taken on and can do no wrong in the managers eyes.

Just watched the "highlights" of the widnes game and our defence is terrible, no structure and no real power behind our defending hits, hope it gets sorted.

Wouldnt pick disko over Heath in a month of sundays, he may have more experience but i think he is to slow when we need speed from dummy half.

After announcing Carvells signing this feels like being slapped round the face with a wet fish !
Underwhelmed to put it mildly.

What happened to Godwin's return to the Bulls?

Eh? I hope not. Wagga isn't good enough.

Rhinos fans are having the same view of their ex-Bradford coach.

Recon we can do a swap, FC for BM ???

I would be happy with that

If, as it seems, Heath is on his way, then I understand giving Diskin another year. He may not be in the form of his life, but he's pretty reliable.

I think that he's a player that plays well when the forwards are making ground. He's the type of hooker that loves running at a defence that's on the back foot, and playing off the back of a quick play the ball. I'm afraid he hasn't got the players around him at the moment to play to his strengths. If we can add some more grunt to the pack on top of Carvell then next year could be a different story.

Oh dear, this is the last news I wanted to hear, really am starting to lose hope.

I wasn't impressed when I saw this first thing this morning. But, if L'Estrange is on his way as the rumour mill suggests, it turns into not a bad move IMO.

Disko isn't exactly in the form of his life, but we do need someone with his experience to bring O'Brien on and frankly, if we did sack Diskin off, who else are we going to get to do the job? We'd run the risk of either A) Just having O'Brien or B) Having him and someone who's not going to help him develop.

I would have prefered to have had L'Estrange and O'Brien for next year, but if that's not possible, this isn't the worst alternative in the world.

Pretty much sums up my feelings, I just hope we've got a decent deal in terms of salary reduction.. He shouldn't be a top earner now you would hope.

Matt has not had the best of seasons. However we do need a team that sticks together.
The big additions need to come elsewhere. O'brien still needs to learn a lot even as number 2 maybe a big ask for him next year.

If we had the choice, disko or health we know who we'd all choose.

Unfortunately it sounds as though FC won't have that choice, so keeping disko makes sense, especially with a 1 year deal.

He can pass on his experience to AO'B, and I'm happy he is still up to SL (not on recent showing, but we all know form is temporary!)

Personally I'd have had a look at Keal Carlile.

That kid that's made about 20 appearences for 3 clubs in about 5 years?

Id give him a miss, appearance record says a lot about his ability.

He was one of our juniors and would count as 'home grown', though. Not seen much of him since he left to be honest.