Finnigan, Addy and Koppy...

I think Addy's a good prospect. If only we could bring him into a team with a couple of halfbacks. Instead he's learning his trade as a player people are depending on to make things happen.

Finnigan
Menzies
Addy = L'Estrange

Finnigan
L'estrange
Addy

Finnigan
L'estrange
Addy

2/3 could have been Beaver, maybe Koppy.

Jeez...as one with MBB!

Absolutely. I like Addy but I don't think he is suited to 6 or 7 and we're asking him to perform a role that he probably isn't ready for. His kicking was hit and miss today but I think he has a future at 13 for us. I prefer to see him taking the line on a bit and running out wide.

I too see Addy as a loose forward. He's not quite quick enough for either halfback position but he has good skills.

Finigan
Whitehead
Beaver

Beaver
L'estrange
Koppy

Fininigan
Menzies
Lynch

Finnegan
Menzies
Addy

Menzies
Kopczak
Finnegan

Very hard to pick, each player had good moments and also some pretty awful moments

3 pts Addy - tried hard behind a sluggish pack
2 pts Finnigan - OK debut
1 pt Koppy - as Addy, tried hard

L'Estrange
Koppy
Finnigan

Menzies
Finnigan
Addy

Tricky really as they all contributed to a pretty poor effort.

Beaver
Lestrange
Koppy

Finigan (yup, think that's how to spell it

)
Beaver
Worrincy, Who I throw in from left field, not because he was particularly effective (who was?) but I though his hit-ups showed a big willingness to work and if he'd maybe run some better angles............

Finigan....predator, one of the few to look lively in backing up with 2 tries
Menzies.. Work rate and attitude
Le'Strange... just about shaded Addy, Kopchaz, Lynch and Whitehead.

There were some DIRE performances from a few others

Menzies


LeStrange
Finnigan

(1) Menzies
(2) L'estrange
(3) Finigan

thought they should have brought Keith Mumby on for second half !!

T & A seems a little critical of Koppy in terms of his match rating

Thought Kopppy had a couple of decent plunges but that's it. When he was subbed for Hall I wasn't really sure why as he looked fresh.

Defensively he's a bit ponderous IMO so perhaps LSH thought Hall would tighten up the defence?

The votes have been counted and you have spoken. Vinny Finnigan has won your MOTM versus Salford CityReds. Steve Menzies comforably takes second with Heath L'Estrange taking third after a close battle with Danny Addy and Craig Kopczak.

1. Vinny Finnigan - 3pts
2. Steve Menzies - 2pts
3. Heath L'estrange - 1pts

Beaver is now back in contention for the overal top spot and is now back within 2 points of Brett Kearney. Heath L'estrange takes third outright but is still a little way off the top two.

Vinny Finnigan is the 20th Squad member to receive points this year.

1. Brett Kearney - 24.5pts
2. Steve Menzies - 22.5pts
3. Heath L'Estrange - 14pts
4. Matt Orford - 13pts
5. Elliott Whitehead - 10pts
6. Nick Scrutton - 9pts
7. Andy Lynch - 8.5pts
8. Jamie Langley - 8pts
9. Michael Platt - 5.5pts
10. Glenn Hall - 4.5pts
11. Rikki Sheriffe - 4pts
12= Wayne Godwin - 3pts
12= Joe Wardle - 3pts
12= Michael Worrincey - 3pts
12= Paul Sykes - 3pts
12= Danny Addy - 3pts
12= Craig Kopczac - 3pts
12= Vinny Finnigan - 3pts
19. Dave Halley - 2.5pts
20. Chris Nero - 1pt

Late I know but for what its worth

1. Menzies
2. Kearney
3. Addy