Are the two worst buys ever?

Thoughts?

Lance is a good player without a position and to be fair to Josh he seems to have been plagued with injuries since he got here. So no.

Michael O'Connor. No more need be said than that name.

Have you only started watching in the last two years?

Far from the worst.

Im probably still classed as a young fan, so wont know many of the old bad buys haha

but i couldn't imagine anybody being more lazy than Perry?!

I would say no, Lance has never played alongside an experienced 7 for Saints and I think Perry plagued by injury has only been match fit for about 2 games.

Tricky Trindal????


Was it one or 2 games he lasted???

And that was playing in his proper position.

Perry is up there with crap overseas players we've brought in. I'd love to see his £ per hour for playing. He's been a total waste of money but at the time was a very good signing. It's just not worked out for player or club.

I think Lance is a good player but from day one I said he's no halfback and that proved correct. He's tried and tried to convert to a stand off but its not worked. I blame Royce and the club for signing a fullback to play stand off. It's ruined is and ruined him. I hope he goes to Salford and has the time of his life because he's a good bloke and his saints disaster as hit him hard.

Perry is possibily one of the worst signings of the Super League era at Saints - certainly of the last decade. He must be one of our top earners, and a mixture of lack of game time due to injury, and terrible, lazy performances when on the field has made his time here a disaster.

Lance, on the other hand, is clearly a talented player. He is a World Cup winning full back who was signed as a half back. Full back is probably his strongest position, but since he's been here he has had Wello and Lomax, and at times Tommy Mak ahead of him. If we were short at #1, he'd have been a success. Unfortunately he's not a #6 or a #9 - and now can't even get any game time.

In hindsight, both signings have failed. Expensively.

I wouldn't mind seeing his £ per yard made

It would sound like the most expensive carpet ever ever


Perry has had a wonderful vacation and probably seen all of Europe's hot spots at our expense during his stay

Please don't forget, he showed off his own hot spots running down Prescot Road