Given the notice and lack of game time this season thought he did very well. Not roby but a decent deputy

Did okay but clearly a very limited player. Distribution was fine.

He was ok, but got sucked in for the 2nd try I think it was.

In the end Flanagan was just as good at dummy half. We did not need a hooker, we needed a halfback.

Also we missed Lomax at FB. There was less speed running at the opposition and a lack of organising the defensive line that Lomax does so well.

Makinson did ok, but not in Lomax's class.

Makinson suffers greatly from being dropped into positions without time to prepare. Lomax to fullback was agreed in the off season so he will have had lots of time to prepare.

If Gardner is out injured again I expect to see Makinson back on the wing. I do hope if that's the case that Percy is played inside of him. I'm dying to see that as a wing/centre combo!

Thought Howarth had a pretty decent game to be honest especially as it was a debut game. he has a good pass technique throws the ball out wide missing out players for a quick attack on the fringes.
If he improves which I imagine he will when he gets familiar with the team, then I think he will be a good attribute,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, perhaps McManus and Brown have got this one right with Howarth, time will tell.

No he clearly isn't, jeez man get a grip he only joined you two days ago give him a chance - some fans are genuinely mental.

I hope we don't put Percival on the wing again, it pushed one of our better threats to far out wide to have an impact.

I'd have maybe reshuffled Turner to half, wellens to FB, Makinson to wing when Ade went off. Jones to Turners slot. But we were runnning out of troops.

This season is looking like 2011 revisited.

I thought he had a pretty good game, he put in some good tackles and his distribution was alright.

Solid. Did his job well.

His distribution was decent and I thought he did well. He only had one training session with us!

If he continues to do a job over the next few weeks, then I think he could be much needed back up for Roby.

He did well. He takes his time getting rid of the ball, but his distribution was accurate and he worked hard.

Different sort of player to Roby. Howarth is never going rip a defence apart with his running, and Roby is a dynamo in defence. But I think Howarth's distribution is actually better. He's more an old-style dummy half (reminded me a little bit of Lowes)

When at dummy half he seemed to opt for playing the ball on the blind side an awful lot, and it rarely looked like the right decision.

I did think he looked a little slow getting the ball out. I thought a few times he was going to get caught with the ball. But I did not want to be too critical as it was his first outing and I did not want it to turn into a pro-Gaskell Anti Howarth campaign.

With one day in the team we could not expect a lot.

Considering he's only had one game training with the team, he did alright, especially in such a big game. I was pleasantly surprised by his performance.

I thought he did ok today but with the adrenalin surging through him in a good Friday debut against his former club that's only to be expected.

His real tests will come in a month or two's time when the honeymoon period is over and done with. I'd be surprised if he's till in your side come the important game at the back end of the year tbh.

I think that's very harsh, his distribution was fine. The fact we had no structure to our play throughout the game meant he was having to evaluate the situation and choose the best pass, rather than following set patterns. He's certainly a class above Nathan Ashe.

Did nothing particularly bad, did nothing particularly brilliant.

Comments about his distribution are fair but John Clarke does that bit well.
Hardly going to frighten defences, He is not the answer.

Agree, he did a pretty good job under the circumstances. His pass variation looked better than Roby,s, he certainly performed better than the pre match judgement opinions of him.

Just.

Unfair to pass judgement on him in the circumstances. However, I did think any of his short hit up passes were forward (I know everybody passes flat) but that may have been ue to lack of familiarity with his team.

I thought he did alright considering the circumstances.

He isn't a world beater, but he will do a job, and he did just that. His distribution was accurate, and he worked hard up the middle. As he progresses, the more confident he will become, and hopefully we will see him kick on now.

Watching it back his distribution is excellent and his tackling is good. He is never going to be a blockbuster style hooker like Roby but he does the basics thing very well.

Delivered more than expected for me today.

Did we sign Cameron Smith? I'm pretty sure we signed Stuart Howarth myself.