Because he wasn't at fault for any of the three tries.

It's an interesting point. Does anyone have Makinson's record anywhere? For a player that gets rave reviews, he never really seems to score many tries and he has a decent centre with him. He's never done anything inidivually, he doesn't score long range tries like Huddersfield's backs do.

Foster did nothing wrong bar drop one ball. If we're dropping players for that Wello wouldn't have played at all last season as he dropped pretty much every single bomb that went to him.

You said that in the other thread, but it isn't true. Shortly after dropping that ball he came in off his wing unnecessarily and allowed Blanch to score a crucial try. He did a similar thing earlier in the game as well.

Lol, I said this on another thread.

No lynch mob for makinson yet????

Or Ade for bombing a simple catch?????

In the end it was a good game, with 2 good teams, seperated by one point. We could have won, it's about building form, if we take that forms forwards then the victories will come, lets hope it's not a false dawn.

It wasn't all his fault. He's had Gary Wheeler as his centre, who is defensively woeful as well. You don't drop a player for one poor performance. When is it Wello's turn? His last good performance was 2007.

That ain't salt.

Didn't say it was

It's Rogues' jar of 'special' powder.

Lomax shot out of the line for their first try whilst Gaskell's poor kick and our chronic lack of pace led to their third try.

I noticed Jamie scored 5 trys and kicked 10 goals for your academy side at the week end. Has he really gone that bad? also wasnt he your top try/points scorer last season?

No.

Sorry thats what I mean't - the dobbins game.

is foster gonna play this weekend against hull?????

only the Royce Simmons "random squad selector" app knows the answer to that.

Apparently Makinson and Flanagan are both out this weeked, so I'd expect to see Foster against Hull.

So has St Pete seen it first hand?

Injury so Foster is back.

The question I have to ask is, was Makinson injured last week, he did not kick the goals and it's a thigh injury this week?

No problems with the squad this week, other than me having to change my fantasy team again to rotate foster back in.

My only issue with the squad is that I think I'd have had Magennis in there.

Otherwise all good.

Seen what first hand?

I think he maybe a late replacement for Flanaghan. But will probably not make the 17. Would be nice to see all 5 props in the team for once.

Do I detect some jealousy here

no,

Whatever prick