I'm not sure I rate Moore from what I've seen. To be fair I've not seen a great deal of him this year.

I thought he was very poor on loan at cas but that was pretty poor cas team and he was still very young.

I just hope we don't lose roby's impact from the bench if we go with KC and Moore as our hookers.

IMO in the games I've seen him he makes a lot of mistakes and doesn't offer much going forward.

It depends whether he can be bothered. The chances of him delivering over a full season may be slight. I think you would be nuts to move KC or Roby for Scotty.

However if you want someone to go awol, skip training, not be upfront with your coach at a crucial time in the season....he may be your man.

Maybe he isn't happy at Hudds?

Hells fire Moore wouldnt get in our award winnign a-team right now, he looks totaly bereft of form and ideas. He needs to get back in tellins sharpish, have a few ales with his pal Mickey Rourke, have a game of poker with KC and get ready for a 2010 WOW of a season.

Which team's that then?

The award winning one

He has really lost his form in the last 8 weeks or so. Prior to that he was excellent. Maybe he is upset about the thought of having to go back to Saints

Better than Roby and Cunningham on form this year pal........Look at the SL Dream Team

Thought he wasn`t much cop before he went on loan, haven`t seen out to change my mind, Huddersfield can keep him for me.

He's been picked for England and has made the Dream Team, so he can't have done too badly.

Yet still not good enough to pull on the Red V for some, eh?

Its only my opinion, to which im entitled, as you are to yours, i just don`t rate him, never have, never will. As for his dream team inclusion, think we all know what a farce some of those selections were

he could get the golden boot some wouldn't be happy!

The fact jammer isn't in dream team makes me think the dream team is a farce.

Good to see you're open minded

IMO you have milked the squad for a season too long, the coach is not as good as your last couple of coaches and the team is a season past it,

the solution being get rid of the whole squad and the coach?

And the stadium. Only Stan Wall to be retained, and Hattons Solicitors.

I confidently predict that Scott Moore will be next season's whipping boy on this forum. People seem to be expecting that we'll be getting a complete player who can waltz his way into KC's boots. From what I've seen he's (still) a young player with lots of potential, but is prone to lapses in concentration in both attack and defence.

He may turn out to be a good player for us in the long run, but in the meantime I expect him to be on the receiving end of a torrent of irrational abuse.

Sounds good to me. I like a bit of scandal.

Perhaps we'll see 'Sack the board' posters and people storming the directors box again?

Well it's got to be someone, hasn't it? Meli is playing too well for it at the moment, but my money will still be on Gardner for next seasons 'scapegoat' award. Potter this year, Gardner next, then Webcke when he comes out of retirement for us the year after.

Webcke isn't going to come out of retirement, he could just sell one of the 14 houses he owns in St Helens.

The will always be players getting whipped on here and it's mostly the same players.

Meli, Gardner are the fave to be slagged off on here. Meli has been in our top 3 players over last 2 month but everyone bangs on about his mistakes.

I think foz will get a lot of stick next year as people think its going to be the the same foz we had but he's a shadow of the player.

On the subject of Moore, he's not as good as saints fans think and will be a whipping boy.

Where are people banging on about Meli's mistakes on here? This forum has been pretty quiet where Meli is concerned for some time now. Probably because he has been playing so well. Which he has. And I hope that continues for as long as we have left of our season.

I've read a good few posts where meli been slagged off but can't be d looking through them.

When we lost to Leeds the other week people was banging on about the kick he dropped but was still our best player that night.

The hudds game last week meli was outstanding yet got bagged for that bad pass.

Yet other players make same mistakes but nothing said.

Are you stalking me by the way?