Sounds nasty sports.yahoo.com/top/news?slug=ycn-8001494

Sounds nasty sports.yahoo.com/top/news?slug=ycn-8001494

I don't think we're gonna see him again in a Saints shirt.

Maybe, if his Saints career is over, this may allow us to bring in someone else?

I do agree with the speedy recovery bit, hopefully it is not a career ender, but not the divided opinion bit. Perry is one of the few subjects we all agree on.

Always sad news if this is a career ender, but it's a harsh game and if it is over for him, retire him and use his money for a decent halfback now!

I think his wages will still count on the cap. Isn't that what happened to Luke Davico at Wigan? But then again somehow HKR found a way around it to deregister Michael Dobson.

de-register only took him off the quota not the cap.......HKR were under the cap. If he is out for rest of season then he can be de-registered to bring another quota player in as long as whatever they have paid Perry to date and any severance for rest of contract plus new players salary is still under the cap.

Dugan for Perry.

Not to batter a point. But has Dugan ever played as a half???

Do we want another quality fullback to play half back, we've made that error once already.

If a prop goes, do we not need another prop???

I'm all for getting names in, but we also need a balanced side. We are swapped with fullbacks at the moment and just putting a 6 or 7 on their back ain't going to make them a half.

Quote ="bewareshadows"Dugan for Perry. Not to batter a point. But has Dugan ever played as a half??? Do we want another quality fullback to play half back, we've made that error once already. If a prop goes, do we not need another prop??? I'm all for getting names in, but we also need a balanced side. We are swapped with fullbacks at the moment and just putting a 6 or 7 on their back ain't going to make them a half.'" Comments here www.news.com.au/breaking-news/br ... 6601751021 would suggest he wouldnt make a good half

Quote ="bewareshadows"Dugan for Perry. Not to batter a point. But has Dugan ever played as a half??? Do we want another quality fullback to play half back, we've made that error once already. If a prop goes, do we not need another prop??? I'm all for getting names in, but we also need a balanced side. We are swapped with fullbacks at the moment and just putting a 6 or 7 on their back ain't going to make them a half.'" Comments here www.news.com.au/breaking-news/br ... 6601751021 would suggest he wouldnt make a good half

I would suggest that a "Pack Leader" is something we are missing.

Given we also have the possibility of losing TP and Boof aswell, props will be on our shopping list.

If this is it for Perry, and we could get someone in instead if him, it'd be like having a free extra player. Top class props are hard to come by though, probably better a loan deal til the end of the season. But personally I'd rather spend any available funds and quota space on a real halfback

Think of Duggan as being at Jamie Lyon's level. He would be comfortably the best player in Super League. If there is a possibility of getting a player of that quality then IMO you do not pass it up.

He isn't the organising, controlling half we've lacked since Kyle left, but with him at 6 in the same sort of role Leon Pryce had, we would have the most destructive and exciting player in Super League. Wilkin or Hohaia could then do the scheming and we would be significantly improved.

If it were a case of Duggan for one season or Dobson permanent, then I would go with Dobson. But Duggan for 2 years ala Lyon is something we should not pass up if its at all possible. He is an outstanding player.

sometimes saddend i question if you even watch the NRL, on jamie lyons level? he's not even on the same planet as jamie lyon... yeah sometimes he does exciting breaks or has the odd flash of brilliance. hes been poor and injury prone since last years state of origin.

Actually i would compare him to a more experienced kallum Watkins with a really spoilt bad attitude.

What nonsense. The boy is dynamite on the field. Brisbane Broncos were going to offer him a massive contract before his latest act of rebellion on twitter. They wouldn't do that for a player on a level with Watkins.

Dugan is a special player, if he does come to SL then whoever signs him will have by far the best player in the league.

So after a little count up our injuries atm stand at: Lomax, Gardner, Roby, Perry, Puletua, Manu, Wheeler, Walker, Flanagan and maybe Clough after today?

We have had rotten luck with injuries so far!

Stolen from Bilko.


Wigan now only have 5 ever presents this season. London (2), Salford (2), Widnes (3) and Saints (4) have less with both hulls equal.

That doesn't quite show the full extent of ours. If I'm not mistaken every member of our 31 man squad has featured.

Has Forster?

Nope don't think he has, you're right.

He must be the only one not to play so far then.

Did anyone properly see how Flanagan picked up his injury? It seemed that the Hull KR bloke went in at his standing leg in the tackle.

Same as Puletua! Its a *ouse trick and needs stopping quickly! Before it ends someones career.

It won't be banned until Eddie and Stevo start a campaign for it!