Because he is a better coach. Bluey as you call him is living off Tony Smiths side, as Hanley did at saints with McRae's squad in his short reign

tony smith was living off darryl powells side

To a degree definitely, but he improved an already good side, IMO bluey hasn't

I could only just manage to reply with a



Once he gives a good argument regarding squad development by both coaches I may respond

Here’s your starter for 10 Saint Simon, How many academy players did McLennan give a debut to in his first (championship winning) season? and how many did Smith in his 4 year tenure?

How, in what possible way does that mean the he is a good coach?

Wrong answer

You still haven't explained how he is "living off" Smiths team?

And how Smith built that team himself?

Your question was about bringing academy players through.

Its just my opinion, that he hasnt improved your side were again IMO Tony Smith did, no need for explanation just an opinion

In his firts season we got more point and had a better points difference than in smiths last season.

He retained the title.

So he did improve, in that respect.

In terms of style i don't believe we have improved but we were already evolving that way under smith anyway.

Hudders never showed up. Leeds won comfortably but didn't show me anything that would scare the S men at this moment in time.

I see what your saying, but how much influence did he have on getting those players together?

Very good reviews mate



Shame that your predictions let you down though