Shame for the lad - has had a cracking season.

I don't buy into this "karma" rollocks, it was a routine obstruction that any player would have made.

Hope he makes a full and swift recovery.

lets hope he doesnt

Joel Tomkins is the most penalised player in SL - I assume you want a career ending injury for him?

Now you see, at least this wigoon troll Is being honest.

Not remotely bothered about McGuire myself. I wouldn't wish an injury on anyone, but we've been hit hard in the halfbacks (and everywhere else) but still worked damned hard to get to where we are. No doubt the Sky guys will be eulogising as if he's dead. But for me, all I can see is slightly less hassle should we win our semi and end up facing Leeds.

I think people were thinking about the four nations down under. I was hoping he would miss the remainer of the GF offs and poss GF but be back at his very best to face the convicts on 31 Oct.
The goon threads seem to think he deserves all he gets with some hoping he is out for good / end of career which is pretty disgusting.



If its as bad as it now seems, he will be out at the start of next season as well and even though I'm no fan of his, I really feel for him.

Has anyone considered that he injured himself before he grabbed carmont i.e. in trying to catch him? I might have this completely wrong but normally mcguire would have easily caught the goon, so did he grab him in the act of going down (sic).
Brian McClennan seemed all steamed up on sky about how he thought the injury occurred.

He's an idiot. In his world, his lads never do anything wrong. Personally, I take anything he says with a pinch of salt.

So are you.

Oh another note, we've had one half back for 17 of the 27 rounds. Which is quite bad going, but Sinfield has filled in well enough. I know its not on your scale though.

Does this change who we send to leeds, making them an easier team to beat, would you send the lower ranked team there making it a more even game?

You're a sharp one!

I'd send whoever is the better bet to finish them off.

McGuire has been quality this year. Has well and truly hit back at all the people (me included) that said he was just a good support player. Has really developed all aspects of his game. Hope he recovers and can reproduce the form in the 4 nations.

typical plat waz moron. I wouldnt mind him missing a few games but nobody deserves a severe injury. If your cheesed off because your team of bottlers lost and have something against players who undertake in cynical professional fouls to gain advange I take it your not a big fan of Sneaky Sam Tomkins?

Just found out hes Ruptured his crutiate ligermant and other ligermant damage...very simular to sia's injury 4 us early in the year!!!

Massive loss for Leeds and England.
hes been outstanding this season.

we have had this discussion before and you live a heck of a lot closer to the waz than I



when I posted this, there was no news on McGuire and I along with several thousand others thought he was feigning injury to avoid being sent off for the cynical professional foul he did. I honestly thought he would be back in the semi-finals.

I wouldnt wish this type of injury on anyone. It has done your lot a favour as Leeds stand no chance of winning the play-offs now as McGuire is their one player who has been in good form recently (in fact the whole season), maybe they wont beat the stains 3 in a row now.

as for Sam, I have never seen him do a professional foul ever, please enlighten me. Though I would not put it past him had he been in McGuires boots on Sunday

You were posting in a thread entitled "McGuire out for the season - confirmed".

Either you're a liar or you're pretty stupid.

has the title not been changed?
what time was the announcement re McGuire's injury?
What time was my post?

I rest my case, m'lud

1. No, unless a MOD has done a cracking job and changed the RE:s aswell.
2. About the same time as the OP yesterday.
3. You tell us

No.
Before I started the thread, obviously.
After mine.

a very nasty injury, but hard to sympathise with an injury sustained while committing a foul. A bit like JJB a couple of weeks ago and Morley's eye socket. Live by the sword die by the sword.

I still don't see it so can't agree. He offers plenty for Leeds in SL but at international level I don't think he gets the room and is far less effective.

Terrible injury either way - maybe their daft Yiwi coach has brought this on his club with comments earlier in the year!

That though is Leeds season done I think (holds breath and thinks he's spoken too soon)

Never write off the rhinos.

We'll still have webb, burrow sinfield and smith for the attack.

We have 2 weeks to shape up and prepare for the game without mcguire.

We were in a worse position in 2008 and lifted the title.

No you weren't.

He's looked great whenever I've seen him lately.

I think a combination of him losing his international shirt to tomkins (or a lot of posters assuming its Sam's now) and Leeds not being in pole position has allowed posters to appreciate his game more and give a more balanced opinion.