Quote ="St Ty"I agree with most of your points there. However, loathe as i am to get involved in any debate to try to compare two players, personally i'd rate them both at the same level based on their respective careers, the impact they both had on the game during their time in the top flight and their individual merits - NOT on how they compare to each other in some kind of petty flop contest.'"
Don't disagree and I can understand that Most Saints fans will pick Scully & Vice Versa.
I think I did try to rate them on their own individual merits by mentioning that both had slightly different attributes that brought different qualities to the teams they played in.
That's why I think together they worked well, one could roll his sleeves up a touch more whilst the other could add the cherry on the cake a bit better so to speak.
Currently at Wigan given the e were in at the moment I would probably pick Faz if I could have one back now.
If Wigan were at the Top of the League & looking to a player for a bit of magic to win us a big one then I may go for Scully.
