Decent signing.

Confirmed signing

All in all it’s a good one for me

Good signing that, 27 so coming into hos prime, hard working forward and doesn’t take up a quota spot

Good signing. Primarily played back row does this spell the end for Bentley, still looking for a prop do we think?

Could be a replacement fir Walters / donaldson

Happy with this signing hard working player who's been quite consistent for Catalans last few years. Helps us replace Walters & Tetevano I think as well.

Could potentially be Walters', Donaldson, or Tet's replacement too

Solid signing.

Pleased with this, lets see how he goes. Seems likely Tetavano replacement non quota non marquee.
Hopefully both projects Warren and Ruane kick on next year after a year as full time pros. Replacing Walters and possibly Donaldson, all though I rate Donaldson as a pound for pound good value squad filler.

Any news on Warren after that nearly nasty injury scare?

He was back playing the other week.

Don't know much about him but we needed someone to replace Walters etc

Good signing then by the looks of it. Suspect Tet will likely go and obviously Walters is going. I'd expect another forward at least to come in.

Will depend if Tet stays I think.Not seen Toby Warren but he may get a few appearances.Pleased with signing

Happy with that signing very solid does the hard yards.

Not convinced he's a replacement for Walters he's more a backrower who can fill in at prop.Could well spell the end for Donno or Bentley.

With Walters, Donaldson and Tet leaving its good to have a player coming in who isn't a project

Good to here

Tres bien.

Yeh decent player with a good workrate.
Depends who he is brought in to replace though.
If it's to replace Donaldson, then it's a great signing.
If it's to replace Bentley, it's a decent signing.
But if it's to replace Tetevano, then it's a cheap option and another back rower who's not big enough for prop.
We need to replace Tet (if he is leaving) with a quality front rower, especially now Walters has gone.

Agreed

Decent signing, I do think Bentley and Martin will move on. We need someone bit higher profile in pack too….pack leader type. I’d have Seumanu back!

Cheap shoes again from Gawwy

Don't know much about Goudemand, but so far Smith's signings have been pretty good.

McDonnell, Macdonald, and Lisone (now that he's fit) all look great.

Sangare is a bit more of a work in progress but he hasn't really let us down, and gives us a bit of much needed size and impact in the pack.

Olpherts obviously hasn't worked out, even if not a player who would make it into our first 17, he should have been better than he has been. Can't really comment on the lower league signings because we haven't seen enough of them yet.

Not dancing in the street on this one but if cheap and just a squad man then maybe ok