I don't dispute it one bit and the huddersfield fans who watch him every week will tell you he has improved dramatically, it's just that I haven't seen it myself.

'Better' yet hed still have made more errors and fewer tackle busts and clean breaks?

There is very little between the two players though their strengths are slightly different.

My point isn't that there's any great problem with Crabtree more that there's not much up with Feka.

If you base your appraisal of a player based upon statistics alone.

He's ace. Wish he played for us. Good for the Giants though in getting him signed up.

Or even just a narrow range of statistics - which is what SL site gives.

Either way I'd still stand by the comment that neither lack quality.

You would have if you'd watched the Huddersfield V Warrington highlight package on Boots 'N All this week.

Plenty of special moments from the big lump on there.

Thanks, I may just pop over there and have a look.