Whilst the time is right for the club and McGoldrick to part ways, even Ryan's greatest detractors cannot argue with the loyalty he's shown over the last 6 years.

All the best Ryan and thanks for being a Tiger.

Would of liked to give him a proppa send off he deserves that much, Good luck Goldy

Have to praise his loyalty to the club and disappointed to see him leave, we could have done with his experience over the next few weeks.

Time is right for both parties though. Although not sure why Hull would want him, surely Ellis is a better prospect than someone looking for another year, maybe two then a nice pay off??

Good luck to RM. Not always everybodies cup of tea but I don't think he deserves the nasty comments from some of the cas fans (minority I might say). Was never going to play for us next season so the business has been done, he's sorted and the club are already spending the wages on next seasons players 'win win' for a change.

Couldn't agree more. People go on about his loyalty but he had it on Easy Street when we were relegated (twice) and let's not forget that he had the chance to join the reigning NRL champions in 2006 but he chose to join Cas. Not exactly the mark of a man who whats to get to the top of his chosen profession. I think he has been more of a hinderance (with his inflated contract) to Cas than a help.

and the reason Goldy left is............

Because Cas told him months ago he isn't getting a new contract, someone else offered him an 18 month deal HTH

Because he's been crap since the day after he signed his 4 year deal in 2008?

Quote ="Gronk!"Because Cas told him months ago he isn't getting a new contract, someone else offered him an 18 month deal HTH '" Well it certainly isn't Hull Fc who have offered him an 18 month deal, Read what Gentle says at the bottom of this article www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/18724415

Quote ="Gronk!"Because Cas told him months ago he isn't getting a new contract, someone else offered him an 18 month deal HTH '" Well it certainly isn't Hull Fc who have offered him an 18 month deal, Read what Gentle says at the bottom of this article www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/18724415

you living in hope or desperation ?

hope

Quote ="jacko1" '" www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sp ... witterfeed

Quote ="jacko1" '" www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sp ... witterfeed

Prefer mine it actually has a quote from Peter Gentle



Also no matter what happened he couldn't have played tonight even if he'd have signed yesterday he wouldn't have been registered in time and why exactly does he need to change a work permit ??

Change of employer.

How much of his wages he deferred do you still owe him I wonder?

Read the interview properly, it clearly states that all has now been repaid.





Oops, sorry...I asked you to read and then realised your a Hull KR fan

He said it was all paid back:



So no need to wonder





Some people just like to try and cause bother by asking stupid questions that answer themselves.

Answer me this one then. How come in 2009 Cas were deferring players players wages when in 2006 Cas led the charge against Wigan for deferring wages which as a result of the investigation was then ruled to be "against the spirit of the cap" and so against the rules?

I did read it all properly www.dailystar.co.uk/rugby/view/2 ... eep-going/ There was no mention of it payed back in there which was the piece I posted about

I did read it all properly www.dailystar.co.uk/rugby/view/2 ... eep-going/ There was no mention of it payed back in there which was the piece I posted about

Because Wigan did it to avoid going over the salary cap, Cas did it for financial relief...massive difference.

Wigan cheated, deal with it.

You think we have even come close to breaking the salary cap?



Also in 2009 it was a live cap so the rfl would have been fully aware.

Wigan cheated to stay up, accept it, it happened.

I am sure Wigan could have dreamt up that excuse at the time and there was nothing in the rules (at the time) to preclude what Wigan did for whatever reason. It was basically a witch hunt where a matter of opinion ("spirit of the cap"icon_wink.gif as opposed to a rule was used to get the end result. The irony is that the club that lead the charge against Wigan deferring wages had to do it themselves. The reason is irrelevant.

Apart from it is.

Wigan did it to hide breaking the salary cap and as such avoided relegation - which is cheating.

Now stop trolling.

I cant believe some wigan fans still dont believe they cheated in 06, have you accepted the earth is not flat yet?

Did wigan defer payments to get round the cap in order to cheat the cap and stay up, without the consent of the rfl? yes, that's cheating.

Did cas defer payments with the full knowledge of the rfl that took us no where near the cap and in no way benefit our league position? yes, thats not cheating.

Did Cas try to change the phasing of multiple existing contracts to allow them to sign extra players that would have taken them over the cap?

Or did they just delay the payment under an existing contract as they were struggling for cash, which had absolutely zero impact on their salary cap?