With how unlucky we've been this season with decisions from the ref, I think we finally deserved to be on the right end of some judgement calls.

Bad call got Bulls back in to the game the one where shenton was in the corner been dragged into touch still for life of me dont know what he did.

I guessed that he called Shenny held as he was being dragged into touch. Shenny didn't hear it and offloaded. Only thing i could think of.

Wouldn't that be a penalty though and not a scrum ? Plus he put his hand to is mouth as though it was dissent ? although how you can give a scrum for dissent is beyond me

Seems none of us know then. I just thought he told him to shut up but if he signaled it then surely it would have been a penalty? So if he gave a scrum he must have just thought he went in touch (which he clearly hadn't imo) because there was nothing else was there?

Who you referring to there as widders contracts doesnt run out till 2011 i believe.

Run Fat Boy! timesonline.typepad.com/rugby_le ... entry.html

Run Fat Boy! timesonline.typepad.com/rugby_le ... entry.html

Yeah, it must have gone your way, there was no bottles raining down on to the officials yesterday.



Have Castleford banned them yet by the way?

It was a bad decision, it should have been Bulls penalty, not sure how he could give a scrum.

Dean Widders = legend.

bulls penalty why?

shenton got the ball got to his knees tadusemion toched him twice - IMO tackle completed ref waved play on shentoon got to his feet then three bulls player pushing him into touch so he off loaded to mcgoldrick - play on in my opinion definately not a bulls scrum or penalty!!!

Bulls penalty for the vol. tackle maybe?
Or scrum Bulls for the in touch?
Or penalty Bulls for the gobbing off?

Take your pick.

voluntary tackle how when he fell to the floor to cover the ball - does tadusemi touching him not constitute the tackle complete?

in touch - he off loaded 3 ft before he went near touch.

gobbing off - who whenton are you kidding?

The ref could have tried to let the crowd know what the hell the decision was for though. To put a scrum down and then give the signal for dissent made no sense.

[url=http://www.castigers.com/cgi-bin/tigertv.cgi?159See the Dean Widders try here.[/url

"Get oxygen tank on!"

Quality entertainment.

Why can i not get tired of watching/ listening to that



And i beg any cas fan to try and watch that and not smile

Quality entertainment.

He was onside as well. He went back to the 20m line and the ball was played on the 30.

Lightning pace!

It must still be hard to take defeat then thought you'd have got used to it by nowicon_lol.gif suppose its different than criticising the spelling thoughicon_wink.gif

I disagree. He was a good two yards off side, and was in front of our other defenders.

His tummy was offside though

. Well done Dean that was superb.

The ball was played on the 30m. He was offside when the ball was played but continued going back to the 20m then started going forward. Thus he is onside.