I wouldn't say he's the dirtiest player in SL. But he certainly likes to get the opposition riled up.

1 Olivier Elima
Catalans
12

2 Ryan O'Hara
Celtic Crusaders
10

3 Sean O'Loughlin
Wigan
10

4 Carl Ablett
Leeds
9

5 Mick Higham
Warrington
9

6 Sione Faumuina
Castleford
8

7 Danny Tickle
Hull
8

8 Scott Moore
Huddersfield
8

9 Ryan Bailey
Leeds
8

10 Luke Robinson
Huddersfield
8

11 Adrian Morley
Warrington
8

12 Mitchell Sargent
Castleford
8

13 Joe Westerman
Castleford
7

14 Kevin Sinfield
Leeds
7

15 Ray Cashmere
Salford
7

16 Keith Mason
Huddersfield
7

17 Stephen Wild
Huddersfield
7

18 Andy Raleigh
Huddersfield
7

19 Jason Demetriou
Wakefield
7

20 Greg Bird
Catalans
7

21 Adam Mogg
Catalans
6

22 Peter Lupton
Celtic Crusaders
6

23 Gregory Mounis
Catalans
6

24 David Ferriol
Catalans
6

25 Terry Newton
Bradford
6

Unless my eyes deceive me he's not in the top 25 for giving penalties away.

Terry Newton.

Maybe Benny is just good at not getting caught

Or maybe he's just come back from a lengthy ban so hasn't played as much as the others

Has to be ryan bailey.....the dirtiest player in RL

In terms of niggly stuff in the tackle - McGoldrick by some distance, even players think he's the dirtiest player in the league.

In terms of high tackles etc, Newton, Westwood, Hock or O'Loughlin.

[Justin Morgan mode Any of the Huddersfield first team [/Justin Morgan mode

His five match suspension would suggest otherwise.............

Naw he justs waits till their backs are turned before he gets involved

I thought there were several on the Wire side yesterday, Ganson let 3 mega high tackles go on the trot, culminating with Shifty getting a high shot after a downtown, not one went punished, I honestly think the game is getting dirtier as far as head shots are concerned and lying on at the tackle.
Huddersfield are the leading lights as far as memory serves me.
We'll see on Sunday if Potter has brought his dirty tactics from Catalans with him.

Think we should change title to dirtiest team in SL looking at all injuries we have after playing wire !

Quote ="Rave-on"I've decided to raise this issue after watching, who i think is the dirtiest player in SL which is Ben Westwood. Although a very good player, not one of his tackles yesterday was below the neck and Ganson let him get away with it. Does he know how to bend his back?'" www.therfl.co.uk/about/disciplin ... php?id=921 Have a look here.

Quote ="Rave-on"I've decided to raise this issue after watching, who i think is the dirtiest player in SL which is Ben Westwood. Although a very good player, not one of his tackles yesterday was below the neck and Ganson let him get away with it. Does he know how to bend his back?'" www.therfl.co.uk/about/disciplin ... php?id=921 Have a look here.

Maybe a few lessons from therailwayendisuponus are in order

The difference is Saints don't need to do it. So they don't.

And am I wrong in saying 8 of those players named by Normy Knight have Cas connections???Just a thought!

I would assume that it was foul play that prompted the original poster to start the thread. Whilst you have a valid point, the list posted by Normy Knight doesn't differentiate between foul play and technical offences, which obviously reduces the credibility of the argument significantly.

Has to be Ryan Bailey.

Quote ="danny boy1"We'll see on Sunday if Potter has brought his dirty tactics from Catalans with him.'" www.saintsrlfc.com/news/1698 we were top last year and currently 6th, so to a degree he has, i think our focus has been more on defense this year. Cas are just below us in the table Wakey on the other hand ....

Quote ="danny boy1"We'll see on Sunday if Potter has brought his dirty tactics from Catalans with him.'" www.saintsrlfc.com/news/1698 we were top last year and currently 6th, so to a degree he has, i think our focus has been more on defense this year. Cas are just below us in the table Wakey on the other hand ....

Bailey or Newton

Bailey.... by a country mile.....

The entire Hudds team

Thats the way to do it, start an argument on somebody else's board

He'd love that title, he's the biggest coward thats for sure.
Abblett is a dirty b@stard