Was told he will play at 6 for you next year?

Good signing if true.

I'd certainly take him, especially with him being a local lad, but would be surprised if he was earmarked for 6, with Roberts being ready to hit the ground running after a great end to the year. With the lack of wingers in the squad at the moment, and not 100% sure what the situation with Carney is, we can't really move Solamona to FB, so may be looking at a successor to Dorn?.

Not good enough and wouldn't be committed to the Tigers - listens too much to his family who are WTW.

You need to change your source of information

Why would anyone pick him over Roberts?

Ben Roberts being linked to Saints on Facebook ?

From your comment that he's not good enough, presumably you've watched him play at stand off then? or are you basing your opinion on that knuckledragger at Wigin playing him out of position at full back.

I'm sure he has bags of potential, but would he get selected ahead of Ben Roberts (who granted started very slowly but was fantastic final 10 games or so)

Can't see why we would bother other than for a squad player, he's not as good as Roberts or Dorn

Finn has gone to Wakefield so maybe there is room for Hampshire for a season.

I would take Rocky right away. Played Rugby with his older brother. Was always a class act. Still great now and only young. He can cover plenty of positions so will be great to have. Definitely and upgrade from Finn.

I'd take him off Wigan's hands but i'm not too happy about it just been for a year-long loan. We've been stung by doing this already with Snyd from Salford.

His older brother Aiden works unpaid for your club with the juniors.

Bit of a turnaround, I wonder why the change of mind, and can you explain just how you got stung with Sneyd when he was a Salford player.

We gave Snyd a life-line. He was going nowhere with Salford. He excelled in the first 6 months of his loan spell. Salford knew we wanted him permanently but put a stupid price tag on him (100K). That scenario originated from the Chase deal. Cas and Salford wern't doing business with each other at the time. Only Hull FC were daft enough to pay for him.

in fairness to the bloke he hasn't done bad for us,hopefully even better for us next year

You can't have it both ways, he excelled for you and you wanted him, and I've no doubt if you'd had some brass at the time you would have done a deal for him, so why were Hull daft enough to pay for him?

We don't pay transfer fees lately - same as Rhino's and your lot. You've got Liam Finn on a freeby I see.

We have never paid signing on fees for youngsters, what about signing on fees for your youngsters, do you still pay them?



And your point is what exactly, where does Sneyd come into it?

Signing on fees and transfer fees are 2 entirely different things.

So it's okay to pay a fee for the youngsters and then claim they came through your youth system.

Why are you bothered ??? I'd keep quiet on the subject if the best thing to come through my clubs youth system this decade was Kyle trout

I'm not actually just pointing out how clueless or embarrassed tigerpops is on the subject, fwiw Kyle Trout was far from the best, if he had been I'm sure Cas would have been offering him the moon on a stick to join them as they did with others

Yeah, the one thing that cas need to take them to the next level of regular top 4 finishes and getting to more finals it's Kyle Trout

Leeds, Wigan, Saints and Cas. The big four.

that's the aim, you concentrate on the middle 8's with our 'B' side