Honestly?

Davidson was an total joke, a typical bully who took the ball up once in 2 sets and never tackled. All he ever wanted to do was throw his weight about. Please dont fall for the folly, he was absolute garbage. We have to be looking at the likes of Goldspink and Wrench who were and are true honest players who ran their blood to water for Fax.

a bit harsh about Les. My choices are The Trindernator and Goldspink

Its just my opinion but i couldnt stand the way he strutted about like a peacock and did very little while other guys worked their socks off.

I know he was past his playing best when he came to us, but I was impressed with Faz every time he took the ball up. Going out on a limb here, but would have loved to see him and Goldspink in tandem

Jamie Thackray, on his day he was very very good.

Frank has to be a shout.

Agree with Faz. One of the best props we have had play for us in a while unfortunatley for him along with Mercer they will be remembered for how they went coaching us instead of how well they performed on the pitch for us.

Agreed, we sadly got Faz at the twilight of his career.

I think Birchall was a vastly underrated player for us, so unlucky with his injuries.

Think people are missing the obvious first choice - Jim Gannon.

My mate always seemed to stick up for Birchall, and the games that he did play I watched out for him, but he never really stood out. He had the same style of play as Cherryholme last season. Run it in and drop.

Andy Shickell hahaha

He'd get my vote. Wrench and Shickell for me.

Both players who haven't and weren't given a real chance at showing what they can do, but when they have played they've never stopped working.

Thackray...Wrench...Goldspink...Birchall...Frank

Is this thread just for mentioning ya mates? Frank I would not put in the list, same for Birchall, I also agree about the Davidson comment, just seemed to play the pantomine villian card all the time and not do much work. Id say either Goldspink or what about that kiwi, was it Peter Brown, hmm think he was before the date range actually.

Watene and Goldspink

Not even in the same breath.

Peter Brown was last century mate

1991!

gannon, goldy and watene

I know his appearances were limited by injury but I think Matt James is as talented as anyone else mentioned so far. Certainly made a massive impact in the games he did play

I understand where you're coming from but Kopzack had better spell at Fax than Matt did IMO. So big Craig as well.

Saeeeed

Faz

Goldspink and Gannon for me..

this hole thread prooves y we have been so week in the forwards and poor in defence over the last decade

goldy and trinder for me. 1 season yes but highly consistant

Screen name says it all.... Brett Goldspink!

When's the vote taking place for this?