Problem was Blackpool AFC were charging an excessive amount for the ground, I read a figure of £60k for the ground and policing, so there's not much left on a gate of 8K.

I would prefer it to be played on a neutral traditional R/L ground but finances as always dictate the choices available,im sure we all have preferences

I think most Fax fans think it is wrong but we didn't make the decision so Powell might as well pipe down.

May be they thought we should n't be using Halliwell Jones as it is the home ground of half the Swinton team.

I don't see anything wrong with the Shay. Make a weekend of it, there is a brand new Premier Inn Hotel with a Wetherspoons near by. Why not stay at "The Old Post Office" pub and Hotel. Early morning breakfast at Wetherspoons (just like we do at Blackpool) move on to, well the choice is yours. Ring o Bells, 3 Pigeons, The Shears, The Pump Room, might even get to the match.
Rail links perfect, bus service excellent. Superb ground with friendly locals and excellent staff.
Where else, can provide that, within the budget that can be afforded.
Leigh, miles from civilisation, only the Leigh East bar nearby.
Doncaster, miles from civilisation, no bars nearby.
Dewsbury?
Etc etc.
Don't get me started by suggesting Sheffield, which ground, we wouldn't know till 2 weeks before, and they are both dung heaps, same for the pubs.
No the Shay, you know it makes sense.

I think it's great being at the Shay. It means that if we get to the final it will be like a home tie. What's not to love about that? I might even stay at my folks and get bladdered at the aftermatch celebrations in Liquid. Or the Acca .