Quote ="phil stone"I posted this on the Fev forum (the other one) a while back and thinking about the play-offs and the advantage one club could gain over another in what effectively is a cup competition my opinion hasn't changed.
So where are we with Duel Regestration players?
SL Clubs - Works for them, they can send out the younger players to get experience playing at a decent standard.
Player - On a positive side they are more likely to get game time at a decent level and are challenged to learn different playing patterns and to switch between the two at short notice. On the down side they don't have any stability from one week to the next because they could be recalled at any time.
Championship clubs - Benefit from getting some decent talent to boulster their squads and could help clubs pick up points in the championship they might otherwise not get but the downside is the players can be pulled perhaps after the training session at the beginning of the week then they have to change their planning by bringing in a different player to fill that position
=#FF0000Championship players - No real benefit, perhaps players of a similar age can pick up new tips on fitness and diet but having players coming in and upsetting the balance of the squad, players having to step down one week to make way for the duel reg then drafted back in at short notice can't do much for morale.
Champioship Competition - No benefit whatsoever, actually ruins the competition in a way because some clubs are relying on these players and are probably in a false position in the league as a result.
My opinion is that it should be scrapped, it doesn't enhance the Championship and despite what the RFL might want we are not in existance to support the SL by giving their players match experience.Perhaps if they restricted their imports then these players could get the chance to play in SL more often.'"
Agree completley , It should be season loans or nothing , the other problem though is running any team without a ' support ' team under it , can also create problems